GreatestLaker
#FirePelinka
People still have Melo as a top 5/10 player? This is back to back seasons where a prime Melo is leading his team to one of the worst records in the league. 
The Knicks are 5-25
- Thread starter Yagirlcheatinonus
- Start date
Big Daddy
Fight or die fighting, no surrender.
hoodheronova
All Star
Who is your top 10?People still have Melo as a top 5/10 player? This is back to back seasons where a prime Melo is leading his team to one of the worst records in the league.
AJtheOne
Nets/Giants/Yankees
the Knicks are just awful, watching them play is just 
why did they put these bums on national tv on Christmas
why did they put these bums on national tv on Christmas
GreatestLaker
#FirePelinka
Lebron
Durant
Anthony Davis
Blake Griffin
Chris Paul
Steph Curry
Westbrook
John Wall
James Harden
Kyle Lowry
DeMarus Cousins
Damian Lillard
Dwight Howard
Marc Gasol
Lamarcus Aldridge
I would take all those dudes over Melo.
hoodheronova
All Star
Klay, Noah, Dirk, Duncan...too many to count honestly. Melo isnt a good player.
If you would have said Melo isnt top 10 fine, even top 15 thats fine even top 20 I would disagree but thats your opinion
But now Melo aint even a good nba player. So he shouldnt be on a squad at all right ?
Why coli dudes always gotta go to the extreme. Why is Melo in the association then? Was he ever good player........., when did he become a non good player?
Last edited:
He hasnt been a good player this season. Watch him this year...he's been bad. Liability on D, unwilling passer, black hole on offense....in terms of the contract and what he brings to the floor...it just doesnt match at all.
tremonthustler1
aka bx_representer
did something change?
I've always felt this way about Melo....he's a losing player. But this year, he's been extra bad.
Bullshyt......Black hole on offense, the numbers say he shooting two less shots a game than last yr, three less shots than when the knicks won 50 games, also the assists are up Get out of here with that unwilling passer shyt. And I do watch every single game
If you feel that way about this yr, you have always felt Melo wasnt a "good player" which is completely ridiculous. But it's your opinion not gonna argue with people who never liked dudes game to begin with, it's pointless
It's not ridiculous...there's nothing about Melo's game that I see as a positive. Why would you want Carmelo on your team? His effort on defense today was so piss poor...he doesnt move without the ball...and if you think he's a good passer then we're watching completely different players.
How do you play in the league for 10 + years, while being a completely negative player, I guess you know things that gm's, analyst, current players, former players and coaches don't
