The Official 2025 College Football Random Thoughts Thread

[Silkk]

If it’s white it’s aiiight







I’m jk














Maybe

Mans already preemptively ducking

@Bigwhite2498

 

[K-Deini]

michigan has a first time all american FG kicker and he AINT shyt this year...just missed an easy 34...wtf

And our kicker was apparently the highest rated coming out of high school. shyt don't make no sense.

 

[K-Deini]

Love the goat

 

[Wolfpac]

Love

 

[Ron Mexico]

That boy J Love

Big Noon main event off to a great start.

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

"Preston Stone" from Northwestern might be the whitest name ever

 

[K-Deini]

Bhaahaha. Go irish

 

[Ohene]

bout to turn this off

 

[Wolfpac]

2 plays Irish up 14-0

 

[K-Deini]

Chris ash I owe you an apology

 

[RammerJammer]

draft tape day for LaNorris Sellers I see

 

[Ron Mexico]

They been hyping this Pitt QB for putting up numbers against weak ACC teams.

Finally facing a real defense and he looks like shyt.

 

[Silkk]

Join a real conference

 

[Trav]

in fact i'ma do it, and put all bias aside in good faith...based 100% on college performance

JJ McCarthy
Justin Fields
CJ Stroud
Julian Saiyan [could surpass even JJ to be fair]
JT Barrett
Cardale Jones
Dwayne Haskins [RIP]
Will Howard
Denard Robinson
Drew Allar [better passer than Denard, NOT a better player]
Will Howard
HM: Trace McSorely?

how would you rank your QBs @Trav? clearly you've had the advantage there and would probably rank them better

if we're talking strictly college production and performance, I don't see how we can leave out Heisman award winnin' Troy Smith; that's crazy work. And I know it'll be some slight bias from your end but JJ at the top? I don't think we can confuse being the QB on a title team with being the reason they won it....otherwise, Id slap Krenzel on here somewhere but even Im not that tendentiousness

I got:

Fields
Troy
Stroud
DHask
Howard
JJ
JT
Denard (interchangeable with JT)
Sayin (only this low for body of work so far but he could easily shoot up into the top 2)
McSorley...maybe - I feel like I could get Pryor or Braxton off here if I really wanted to just cuz of how they could literally break games with their legs even if they didn't have the strongest passing.

 

[Trav]

SC