The Official 2025 College Football Random Thoughts Thread

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

if we're talking strictly college production and performance, I don't see how we can leave out Heisman award winnin' Troy Smith; that's crazy work. And I know it'll be some slight bias from your end but JJ at the top? I don't think we can confuse being the QB on a title team with being the reason they won it....otherwise, Id slap Krenzel on here somewhere but even Im not that tendentiousness

I got:

Fields
Troy
Stroud
DHask
Howard
JJ
JT
Denard (interchangeable with JT)
Sayin (only this low for body of work so far but he could easily shoot up into the top 2)
McSorley...maybe - I feel like I could get Pryor or Braxton off here if I really wanted to just cuz of how they could literally break games with their legs even if they didn't have the strongest passing.

i was going only to the James Franklin era (2014), Troy was before that.

I'm sorry bro but Howard over JJ is fukkin criminal and Haskins and stroud over him is wrong. Yall really hate JJ McCarthy lmao

 

[smitty22]

Gonna be great having Dylan Stewart in a Buckeye uniform next year

 

[K-Deini]

Carr the young goat

 

[RammerJammer]

SC

Firing Mike Shula works

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

Carr the young goat

Ann Arbor's finest

[fukk Saline HS tho ]

 

[DCMC]

That catch

 

[Ron Mexico]

what a catch

 

[Silkk]

Coaches get big new contracts and IMMEDIATELY start bullshytting

 

[K-Deini]

A&m gonna cost me a bunch of money today

 

[smitty22]

Beamer talking shyt

 

[K-Deini]

Carr the young goat

 

[Wolfpac]

Carr you big dummy…

 

[K-Deini]

Carr you big dummy…

Can we just give love the ball every down please

 

[Tribal Outkast]

Looking like South Carolina shoulda got rid of their OC weeks ago. If Lanorris really transfers man that’s going to be one of the biggest waste of talents ever

 

[Trav]

i was going only to the James Franklin era (2014), Troy was before that.

I'm sorry bro but Howard over JJ is fukkin criminal and Haskins and stroud over him is wrong. Yall really hate JJ McCarthy lmao

Oh yeah, that's right. Then he gets none on the list for me

No hate breh. We'll just agree to disagree...I know you'll bring up how much talent WH had around him as if JJ's entire team didn't almost make it to the league as well, but if we put his best year (I assume you'd say the chip year) vs Howard's one year next to each other and wipe all names away, it's not close lol