The Pinocchio Paradox.

ℒℴѵℯJay ELECTUA

Return of the Khryst
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
80,069
Reputation
10,429
Daps
124,111
Reppin
ℒℴѵℯJay ELECTUA
What would happen if Pinocchio said my nose is about to grow?
pinocchio.png

We all know that if he lies, his nose grows.

His statement that his nose is gonna grow is a lie. So technically the nose should grow.
But
If by that logic his nose does grow, then he's not lying.

Thus, we have Pinocchio's paradox.
deep throat it!
 

joeychizzle

光復香港,時代革命
Joined
Apr 3, 2014
Messages
12,078
Reputation
4,175
Daps
32,531
Reppin
852
Well that would depend on the intent behind the statement.

Is Pinocchio making a factual statement, or is it something he knows through some predetermined means?

If he's making a statement he deems to be factual, then his nose shouldn't grow in the first place, because he's under the presumed belief that his nose is about to grow - which is in fact not factual. It doesn't make it a lie, it just means that he made an incorrect statement. If you believe a chair is blue, when it is in fact white, does it make it a lie, or does it just mean that you cannot distinguish colors correctly?

If he's making a predetermined statement, that his nose it about to grow and it doesn't, then won't his nose grow eventually? About doesn't really specify time does it? It's not exactly quantifiable. If I say that I'm about to make some breakfast, only I can know quantifiably what I mean by "about". If about to me is 5 mins from now, and I don't make breakfast, then I've stated a lie and my nose will grow. :ld:

Damn that's making my head spin a lil bit
 

NoGutsNoGLory

Superstar
Joined
Dec 22, 2014
Messages
6,648
Reputation
566
Daps
27,608
Not as interesting as the omnipetence paradox (God paradox). If we were to assume god is omnipotent then he can do anything. Say for example we asked god to create an immovable object that even he cant move, thus if he can than he isnt all powerful because he cant move the object but if he cant create it, he is still not all powerful because he cant create said object.
 
Top