There's this miconception that there are 7-10 great QB's in the NFL

[TheNig]

nikka I'm saying Schaub becuz I'm a Texans fan. I ain't finna pull no muhfukkin stats up or none of that. Schaub is my guy.

 

[Dak Pickscott]

nikka I'm saying Schaub becuz I'm a Texans fan. I ain't finna pull no muhfukkin stats up or none of that. Schaub is my guy.

bytch get off schaub dikk. his ass dont win shyt this year he average.

 

[TheNig]

bytch get off schaub dikk. his ass dont win shyt this year he average.

 

[mr. smoke weed]

oh yea schaub is wack to yall too??

 

[Dak Pickscott]

i like schaub. i'd put him before a lot of these overrated chuckers.

 

[CBSkyline]

For me its

Peyton, Rodgers, Brady, Brees, - The Elites

Eli, Big Ben - The Not all the way Elite but we still better than your team's QB


Falco, Ryan, Schuabb, Culter, Rivers, Romo - The Close but no Rings :notimpressed:

Stafford - The I'm stuck

RG3, Luck, Dalton, Cam, Freeman, Wilson, Ponder - The I see some potential/ Future Elites

Fitzspatrick, Smith, Henne, Weeden, Tannehill, Palmer, Vick - The Serviceable/We might not be the best, but we are not total bums

Locker, Campbell, Sanchez, Bradford, Cassel, Gabbert, Tebow, Skelton, Kolb, Foles, - The truly flabby and sick

 

[Stone]

@CBSkyline all the serviceable QBs except for Palmer, Tannehill and Weeden need to be moved down.

 

[Born2BKing]

For me its

Vick, Locker, Sanchez, Bradford, Cassel, Gabbert, Tebow, Skelton, Kolb, Foles, - The truly flabby and sick

nikka don't ever in your fukking lfe compare Mike Vick to them nikkas.

 

[CBSkyline]

nikka don't ever in your fukking lfe compare Mike Vick to them nikkas.

 

[L&HH]

For me its

Peyton, Rodgers, Brady, Brees, - The Elites

Eli, Big Ben - The Not all the way Elite but we still better than your team's QB


Falco, Ryan, Schuabb, Culter, Rivers, Romo - The Close but no Rings :notimpressed:

Stafford - The I'm stuck

RG3, Luck, Dalton, Cam, Freeman, Wilson, Ponder - The I see some potential/ Future Elites

Fitzspatrick, Smith, Henne, Weeden, Tannehill, Palmer, Campbell - The Serviceable/We might not be the best, but we are not total bums

Vick, Locker, Sanchez, Bradford, Cassel, Gabbert, Tebow, Skelton, Kolb, Foles, - The truly flabby and sick

This pretty spot on. Except Flacco's not in the same league as Schaub, Romo, and them he leads the pack of those serviceable qbs and Vick also is also moreso a serviceable qb then a bum.

 

[CBSkyline]

This pretty spot on. Except Flacco's not in the same league as Schaub, Romo, and them he leads the pack of those serviceable qbs and Vick also is also moreso a serviceable qb then a bum.

Wasn't done in any particular order, just off the top of my head, but now that I look at it, Vick is 1000x more serviceable then Campbell Had a lapse of judgement there, happens to the best of us

 

[jetflyinglimousineriding]

Brady, Brees, P. Manning, and Rodgers are on a tier (1a) above everyone else.

Big Ben and Eli are on that next tier (1b) below them.

Then there is the Rivers, Romo, Schaub, and Ryan in tier 2. (RGIII and Luck floor could be this tier)

Followed by Cutler, Freeman, Flacco, and Stafford in tier 3. (Cam floor could be this tier)

Hasselbeck, Palmer, Vick, and A. Smith in tier 4. (Dalton, Tannehill, and Wilson floor could be this tier)

Bradford, Fitzpatrick, and Sanchez in tier 5. (Ponder and Weeden floor could be this tier)

Cassell, Kolb, Tebow, and Skelton in tier 6. (Foles, Gabbert, and Locker floor could be this tier)

 

[VICVALLIN]

oh yea schaub is wack to yall too??

nobody is saying that schaub or even your boy cutler are garbage, just that they're not elite. both have been full time starters since '07 and only cutler has won a playoff game in that span. that's not elite, breh. elite qb are consistent in the regular season and routinely take their teams deep into the playoffs (conference championship or the super bowl). they have done neither.

 

[I AM WE ARE]

what qualifies for elite in some of ya'll opinions? yds? tds? lack of ints? games and championships won?

think about it marino never won a super bowl and the recievers he had weren't stellar to be honest yea the marks were good but nobody picks them for their wr combos

hell is the int pound for pound champ and he's considered one of the greats

big ben doesn't put up monster stats but has 2 sb rings

imo as of right now top 5
brees
rodgers
brady
mannings

 

[JYoung24]

he had elite oline in denver, and he wasnt elite at all. stop being a homer

To be fair he was a young qb though