Caveat tho is that he isn't batting among black people . He only does away games in easier stadiums.
I'd agree 100% if he were batting for Nia long or Journee Smoliet and getting foul balls, but he isn't. A handsome breh by black women standards doesn't really translate to white (or latina) women for cultural and genetic reasons. It's like going from a stadium with high walls that prevent home runs, to a stadium with short walls and slower catchers.
This is what leads me to think his social cues are just funky. If he carried himself differently he'd be killing the game.
The only red flag I see that could translate from black women to white women/ latinas is height. Using the baseball analogy, Shameik automatically starts at the batting mound with two strikes for being 5ft8. Throw in his awkwardness and he is on slim margins.