Timbaland and Pharrell debate which of them produced the best songs for Jay-Z

[Standing on business]

 

[Standing on business]

They were able to debate so confidently because Just Blaze wasn’t there

 

[LadyJ2]

Say the ladies they love me, from the bleachers they screamin’

 

[H. Selassie]

Notable singles are one thing. If we talking deep cuts…give me Just Blaze, Kanye, Bink, Ski, the Hitmen, No ID, and Premo before either of these two.

 

[JustCKing]

They've both given Jay Z some of his best and worst, but I got Timbaland.


I know people love "Allure" and have that as one of Jay's best, but I still feel "I Know" is peak Pharrell/Jay. "Excuse Me Miss" and "La La La" are dope as well. "Oceans" goes too, but it has additional production by Timbaland. The rest of the Pharrell productions on Jay Z albums, I could do without.

I wish they'd quit putting Pharrell and credit The Neptunes as a whole.

 

[Electric Relaxation]

 

[JustCKing]

Notable singles are one thing. If we talking deep cuts…give me Just Blaze, Kanye, Bink, Ski, the Hitmen, No ID, and Premo before either of these two.

Both of them have deep cuts with Jay as well:

The Neptunes- "I Know", "Allure", and "Oceans"

Timbaland- "Come And Get Me", "It's Hot"

 

[Hersh]

Alicia keys

 

[H. Selassie]

Both of them have deep cuts with Jay as well:

The Neptunes- "I Know", "Allure", and "Oceans"

Timbaland- "Come And Get Me", "It's Hot"

Sure. However, no one would ever accuse either of them of producing Jay’s hardest/dopest shyt. Maybe Allure.

The rest…eh.

 

[Sir Richard Spirit]

Kanye eclipses them both. If I had to choose between the two? Pharrell/Neptunes.

 

[Toe Jay Simpson]

Change Clothes was some homo stuff even then

 

[LadyJ2]

Change Clothes was some homo stuff even then

I hate that song fr and I’m a woman

 

[I love Latina women]

The Neptunes, Chad Hugo and Pharrell Williams

Pharrell ain’t do that shyt by himself

I can’t stand how people have started to forget or just flat out don’t acknowledge Chad Hugo’s contributions to their production work.


The Neptunes work with Jay-Z >>>>> Timbaland’s work with Jay-Z

 

[BEN23]

timbaland....jigga what...jigga who..i can keep going..im sorry but allure aint that fire

 

[Buckeye Fever]

They've both given Jay Z some of his best and worst, but I got Timbaland.


I know people love "Allure" and have that as one of Jay's best, but I still feel "I Know" is peak Pharrell/Jay. "Excuse Me Miss" and "La La La" are dope as well. "Oceans" goes too, but it has additional production by Timbaland. The rest of the Pharrell productions on Jay Z albums, I could do without.

I wish they'd quit putting Pharrell and credit The Neptunes as a whole.

I got "Allure" as my #1, but damn, "I Know" is undeniable as well

As far as Timbo tracks for Jay, personally I gotta go with "Paper Chase" and "Originators '99"