I didn't say he was a carbon copy of Devante. just saying his overall style was far from unheard of.
youre confusing commercial with mainstream.
"nikka what nikka who" is the closest he came to a "no more pain". and theres a clear difference between the two. the melodies of "no more pain" alone kills off the jay record. timbo could never put something like that together. he'll give you some goofball sound effects instead.
big pimpin boosted jay-z how?the album jay dropped the previous year sold darn near twice as much as that album. and lol @ "dirt off ya shoulders".
@ pass the courvoiser & drop it like its hot.
those aren't seminal records. and no, I didn't trademark the word "seminal" but I'm dam sure the reason why youre trying to use it right now.
neptunes & timbaland made a heavy impact on radio but they didn't shift anything in HIP-HOP outside of that. and they have nothing to do with the lack of regional sound in the MAINSTREAM. absolutely nothing.
lol @ you trying to move goalposts still. it doesn't matter if the artists you elevate are in your camp or not. I clearly brought up the beat club earlier and how timbaland failed to elevate any of them to a serious standing. that's HIS camp. why would I bring up his camp if camps don't count? he didn't elevate anybody.
and I gave the neptunes props for that already. what are you bringing them up for? this is about timbaland. none of the names you mentioned had a serious hip-hop career. missy is more of star in the r&b realm. basically what she was when she was just doing verses on r&b records before her album even dropped. ms jade could've and should've been a star, which goes to show how weak timbaland is in comparison to some of the names that were dropped earlier, and how hes not the hip-hop guy that yall desperately try to make him out to be. bubba sparxxx & petey Pablo are the best names you can come up with breh? youre proving my point.
Nobody was doing what Timbaland was doing sonically. Again, you'd have to look to the Memphis underground to come close to hearing anything like what Timbaland was doing. The only point of reference in the mainstream is "No More Pain", which is something he helped create.
Mainstream and commercial go hand-in-hand.
The point isn't what melodies kill "nikka What nikka Who". The point was that Timbaland has a track like "No More Pain" in his arsenal when you said that nothing Timbaland has made sounds remotely like that. Where's Devante's other beats that sound like "No More Pain".
Uuum, I'm supposed to be the "number cruncher" according to you, now here you are throwing out sales figures (which are false by the way). "Big Pimpin" indeed helped boost Jay Z. You do realize every single from Vol. 3 was a relative flop compared to "Big Pimpin". On top of that, he had two joints on Jay's biggest album, which led to Timbaland becoming one of Jay Z's go to producers since then.
"Drop It Like It's Hot" is a seminal record. That beat pretty much fathered that whole "A Milli" style of Bangladesh productions. In regard to the word seminal, I used it because I'm responding to the post in which you used it. That happens when people are responding.
Again, The Neptunes and Timbaland changed Hip Hop production. You have their contemporaries like Stevie J. saying he created "Notorious Thugs" as a result of being inspired by Timbaland's production. Mannie Fresh (the guy you have listed in your own top 10) lists Timbaland as one of his Top 5 favorite producers (I guess you can't take him seriously anymore). Kanye is on record saying he was trying to make beats that sounded like Timbaland and Dre's. Current producers from 40 to Boi-1da to Mustard to Mike Will all cite Timbaland as an influence. When Timbaland first arrived on the scene, Hip Hop producers were sampling his work and it was barely a year old. When he produced "Big Pimpin" and "Get Ur Freak On", you had Just Blaze lacing Freeway with "Flipside" and lacing Eric Sermon with "React", Scott Storch lacing Fat Joe with "Lean Back" etc. From 2001-2007, Hip Hop producers were incorporating Middle Eastern and Indian samples into their production.
They had a lot to do with a lack of regional sound in Hip Hop. Most producers of that era worked exclusively with one region. The Neptunes and Timbaland were lacing artists from The East, West, South, and Midwest. Not only that, but listening to their beats, you couldn't tell where they were from.
Missy Elliott is also a star in the Hip Hop world. Her biggest album to date is the one with the least amount of singing and is pretty much an ode to Hip Hop. Her biggest songs feature no singing at all. As for the others, you're lost as to why I brought them up in the first place and didn't even bring up the point (where's Mannie and Beats By The Pound rapper that they boosted or introduced). If camps don't count, it's rather contradictory to claim Mannie and Beats By The Pound are Top 10 all while discrediting Tim, The Neptunes, and Kanye.
Last edited: