You can lie to yourself if you want. Just don't expect me to join in. You know he's never been impressive to watch.
all time talented pocket passer. a text book, really. so yes, he is a tim duncan of NFL. all substance, but bit boring. and he won't wow you because everything happens in the pocket.
But well, if tim duncan never impressed you then brady won't either. because you are basically all on style rather than substance. i guarantee you Brady is in the QB text book because he has the perfect form. perfect efficient release.
Arm strength - B+
I saw a great lively arm.
threw 75 yarder(it was angled, pythagorean theorem proved it traveled somewhere between 75-76yrd)
after he got abused by the giants all 4 qtr in the final minute.
And he is known for 20 yard lasers.
And he was a leader in deep ball yards this year just like in 2007 when he had Moss. Yes, great WRs help QBs.
No he ain't Josh allen, mahomes or Rodgers. but i will shyt on you if you think Brady got a weak arm.
Accuracy - B+
Brady is one of the most accurate passer when he has his leg behind his throws. He has one of the most efficient throwing motion. But he needs to throw with a perfect mechanic to be accurate. He can't angle throws nor he can throw with back foot. But when his feet is set he is as accurate as any. also he leads his WR. more often that not, he finds WRs extra yards because he leads them with throws.
for the record, Rodgers would get A+ because he can do all things brady can, but he can also do it on the run.
Pocket presence/poise/awareness - A
Brady is the quintessential pocket QB. A great feet because he is a jump roper. He knows where the pressure is coming all angles. He was known for staying in the pocket with no fear.
Your boy Josh Allen or whoever is in your top 5 ain't touching Brady in this department except Marino.
Presnap ability - A
This is the greatest quality of Brady. He reads the defense better than anybody. Only Manning is in Brady's level. None. Brady and Manning. that's it. those 2 are god tier.
Mobility - D-
This is Brady's worst trait. He can't throw on the run well. He can't run well. He would rather stay in the pocket and take the sack or throw it away.