Tony Romo or Troy Aikman

[Box Factory]

Championships as a franchise, which you don't have, is always something that will be used against you. Don't be so obtuse.

As an Eagles fan, you should be used to this.

You're basically bragging that your loser QB was better than our loser QB, and missing the point that at least my franchise has had success. Whereas the highlight of your franchise is your loser QB puking in the SB.


I believe Romo was the more talented player between himself and Aikman. I never said Romo was more successful, has a better career, was a champion, or even a winner.


I can't tell if you are straw-manning or if you're actually this dumb.

You brought up McNabb because you were upset other ppl realize Romo has no business being brought up with players like Aikman.

Saying "you have no titles, or choked in the SB" is hilariously ironic when you're making ridiculous statements in favor of arguably the NFLs biggest choke artist of the last 20 years.

Have some perspective

 

[Codeine Bryant]

Don't disrespect McNabb by mentioning Romo with him

If Romo is going to go down as a choking loser, why isn't McNabb the same?


4 NFC CGs and a literal vomit-inducing SB loss


Donovan McNabb has the patents on choking

 

[Surreal]

If Romo is going to go down as a choking loser, why isn't McNabb the same?


4 NFC CGs and a literal vomit-inducing SB loss


Donovan McNabb has the patents on choking

Because he got to those games and with less talent to work with.
He spent his prime throwing to Stinkson and Thrashers and handing off to Duce

 

[Codeine Bryant]

You brought up McNabb because you were upset other ppl realize Romo has no business being brought up with players like Aikman.

Saying "you have no titles, or choked in the SB" is hilariously ironic when you're making ridiculous statements in favor of arguably the NFLs biggest choke artist of the last 20 years.

Have some perspective

Seems like the thread flopped and more people are on board with Romo than Aikman.

So I'm not sure what you're talking about


McNabb is actually the NFL's biggest choke artist.


4 NFC CGs and a SB. 0 titles.
It's like he was literally trying to let you down as brutally as possible.

Romo's resume doesn't compare to that.

Also, Romo leads NFL in 4thQ comebacks and GW drives since 2006. So how exactly can he be the "NFL's biggest choke artist" when the stats actually say the exact opposite?


The stats are lying, right? Somebody got the NFL's password and doctored the books?

 

[JLova]

Romo is the more talented, skilled & athletic QB by a landslide, but not a winner. Aikman had champion intangibles and had the alpha male killer instinct, in other words a winner.

Aikman had:

Helps when your entire team is stacked. Aikman is the most overrated HOFer by a landslide.

 

[Codeine Bryant]

Because he got to those games and with less talent to work with.
He spent his prime throwing to Stinkson and Thrashers and handing off to Duce

What about when he had prime TO and prime Westbrook?

And Jevon Kearse and Brian Dawkins?


What happened then?

 

[David_TheMan]

Seems like the thread flopped and more people are on board with Romo than Aikman.

So I'm not sure what you're talking about


McNabb is actually the NFL's biggest choke artist.


4 NFC CGs and a SB. 0 titles.
It's like he was literally trying to let you down as brutally as possible.

Romo's resume doesn't compare to that.

Also, Romo leads NFL in 4thQ comebacks and GW drives since 2006. So how exactly can he be the "NFL's biggest choke artist" when the stats actually say the exact opposite?


The stats are lying, right? Somebody got the NFL's password and doctored the books?

Using yoru criteria, Jim Kelly is the biggest choke artist, not McNabb.

That said I think Romo would have won the Super Bowls that Troy won if he was on those teams. Aikman would never have had the Cowboys competitive and in the mix if he was on the Romo teams IMHO.
So I'm going with Romo, plus I could never pick a racist like Aikman.

 

[Nintendough]

Aikman had:

Helps when your entire team is stacked. Aikman is the most overrated HOFer by a landslide.

Romo wouldn't have won shyt even with Smith, Prime and C-Collar Irving.

 

[Box Factory]

Seems like the thread flopped and more people are on board with Romo than Aikman.

So I'm not sure what you're talking about


McNabb is actually the NFL's biggest choke artist.


4 NFC CGs and a SB. 0 titles.
It's like he was literally trying to let you down as brutally as possible.

Romo's resume doesn't compare to that.

Also, Romo leads NFL in 4thQ comebacks and GW drives since 2006. So how exactly can he be the "NFL's biggest choke artist" when the stats actually say the exact opposite?


The stats are lying, right? Somebody got the NFL's password and doctored the books?

Again you're playing the "losing early is better than getting to the Conference Championship or Super Bowl " game. Its nonsense.

Romo is like 2-8 and playoff and week 17 elimination games. With several historically horrible performances in those games. The offense skill position history around him is littered with HOFers too. Witten, T.O and Dez. One of the best offensive lines ever. Guys like Barber and Murray at their absolute peak.

And there is no success there? Nothing? Not even one year he couldn't put together a playoff run? Its pathetic

McNabb did way more with way less. McNabb was going to NFC championships and the SB with Todd Pinkston andJames Thrash. Kevin Curtis is one of the top receivers had during his career with the Eagles. The year he had T.O for the playoffs, T.O missed every game except the Superbowl and McNabb still carried them all the way to that game.

No one cares about comebacks in September and October.

 

[LurkMoar]

keep this shyt in house



Lets not do this brehs, just focus on the future with Dak

 

[Codeine Bryant]

Again you're playing the "losing early is better than getting to the Conference Championship or Super Bowl " game. Its nonsense.

Romo is like 2-8 and playoff and week 17 elimination games. With several historically horrible performances in those games. The offense skill position history around him is littered with HOFers too. Witten, T.O and Dez. One of the best offensive lines ever. Guys like Barber and Murray at their absolute peak.

And there is no success there? Nothing? Not even one year he couldn't put together a playoff run? Its pathetic

McNabb did way more with way less. McNabb was going to NFC championships and the SB with Todd Pinkston andJames Thrash. Kevin Curtis is one of the top receivers had during his career with the Eagles. The year he had T.O for the playoffs, T.O missed every game except the Superbowl and McNabb still carried them all the way to that game.

No one cares about comebacks in September and October.

I never said Romo was better than McNabb.

So relax, guy.



But make no mistake, your beloved QB is a choking loser.


:jjumad:

 

[JLova]

Romo wouldn't have won shyt even with Smith, Prime and C-Collar Irving.

Aikman wouldn't have won shyt with those Romo teams. Aikman was just a caretaker, nothing more.

 

[mrken12]

I never said Romo was better than McNabb.

So relax, guy.



But make no mistake, your beloved QB is a choking loser.


:jjumad:

You had one job.

 

[jay211]

Thread/

Agreed. Aikman shined bright when he was under pressure.

 

[El Bombi]

Because he got to those games and with less talent to work with.
He spent his prime throwing to Stinkson and Thrashers and handing off to Duce

Exactly.

Romo need the All-Madden Team to win.

While Cam had the #1 offense and won the MVP with this

Carolina would've been below .500 if Romo was the QB.