Tony Romo or Troy Aikman

[Surreal]

Exactly.

Romo need the All-Madden Team to win.

While Cam had the #1 offense and won the MVP with this

Carolina would've been below .500 if Romo was the QB.

Romo is garbage and set back the franchise
Got fans out here/in here accepting mediocrity

We the damn Cowboyz..hello?

 

[El Bombi]

Romo is garbage and set back the franchise
Got fans out here/in here accepting mediocrity

We the damn Cowboyz..hello?

Exactly.
Thank GAWD this Romo era is finally going out the door.

The last 13 years has been a complete waste of time.

 

[Spade]

Aikman wouldn't have won shyt with those Romo teams. Aikman was just a caretaker, nothing more.

Nobody, not even Joe Montana, Peyton Manning, Drew Brees, Aaron Rodgers, or Tom Brady would win with a team coached by Wade fukkin Phillips and Jason Garrett and headlined by Skeletor posing as general manager.

 

[JLova]

Exactly.
Thank GAWD this Romo era is finally going out the door.

The last 13 years has been a complete waste of time.

Tony Romo Lifetime stats: 247 TD 117 INT 65.3 Cmp% 97.1QB Rating

Some a yall truly retarded.

 

[zopaco317]

Romo is the most underappreciated qb this era, he has put this team on his back the last 10 years. After parcells + payton left, jerry made some dumbass decisions that would set any team back and romo somehow always had the team in playoff contention. The team let romo down exponentially more than romo let down the team, cowboys would have been browns status without him.

 

[Maxine Shaw]

Tony Romo Lifetime stats: 247 TD 117 INT 65.3 Cmp% 97.1QB Rating

Some a yall truly retarded.

Lifetime stats, yes, but he seems to lack some sort of killer instinct. I don't even know why. He's an outstanding QB...has the rest of the team been THAT bad all this time?

At this point, I feel the way Jimmy did w/Hershel Walker. We're terrible with him, so we might as well be terrible w/o him.

 

[Surreal]

Romo is the most underappreciated qb this era, he has put this team on his back the last 10 years. After parcells + payton left, jerry made some dumbass decisions that would set any team back and romo somehow always had the team in playoff contention. The team let romo down exponentially more than romo let down the team, cowboys would have been browns status without him.

 

[DosCadenaz]

Love both

 

[Box Factory]

Love both

Both are in the top whatever of most overrated QBs ever

 

[getmoney310cpt]

Aikman shined when the stakes were high. Romo is the exact opposite.

 

[ReturnOfJudah]

Only on thecoli

 

[MooseMouthMthafuga]

Aikman was middle class man's Trent Dilfer.Team was just loaded.Romo>>>

 

[feelosofer]

Tony Romo was actually a considerably better QB in terms of skill than Troy Aikman. Aikman was smart and stayed within the system but he was surrounded by HOF level players protecting him and on the skill positions.

If anything you could make the argument Romo was underrated in his era.

 

[DosCadenaz]

Both are in the top whatever of most overrated QBs ever

I’ll sock you

 

[Ozymandeas]

People just gotta accept Jerry struck lightning in a bottle. It's not happening again.

It doesn't take 30 years to build another Super Bowl contender.

In those 30 years, Denver, Green Bay, Baltimore, New York, St. Louis/LA, Philadelphia etc. have all figured out how to win with multiple teams/rosters, and other teams like Carolina and San Francisco have at least gotten to the Championship multiple times. Dallas is always fukking up, some way or somehow. You don't even gotta draft a QB. You've had multiple chances to trade or grab guys in free agency.