Too soon? Where will Wrestlemania 30 rank all time?

[NOSaintsFan02]

Top 5? Top 10? In the 11-20 range?

 

[Dog Based Gremlin]

top 10

1. Wrestlemania 3
2. Wrestlemania 17
3. Wrestlemania 14
4. Wrestlemania 15
5. Wrestlemania 19
6. Wrestlemania 24
7. Wrestlemania 30

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

top 10

1. Wrestlemania 3
2. Wrestlemania 17
3. Wrestlemania 14
4. Wrestlemania 15
5. Wrestlemania 19
6. Wrestlemania 24
7. Wrestlemania 30

3 is top high but those are definitely the top tier of manias

 

[NOSaintsFan02]

This one may have been the most historic WM. What will hurt it is there wasn't any bonafide classic match, unless people want to consider Bryan/HHH or Bryan/Orton/Batista a classic.

 

[Riley Escobar]

I thought overall it was the best Mania in a long time. Probably top 5 status

 

[Mr. Manhattan]

Lets see
19
17
10
24
20
21
22
28

30 was good i wouldnt put it up there with the ones i listed cause of the shytty card, it was a weird Wrestlemania definetley produced a
Top 3 shocking moment in wrestling history but thats about it

If they would have had Wyatts vs Shield in a special stipulation match
And took away that shytty tag team match, and that weak Cena match it wouldve definetly been top 5

 

[No_bammer_weed]

top 10

1. Wrestlemania 3
2. Wrestlemania 17
3. Wrestlemania 14
4. Wrestlemania 15
5. Wrestlemania 19
6. Wrestlemania 24
7. Wrestlemania 30

Wrestlemania 15 was ass....one of the worst of all time. That was the height of Russo booking....there was like one decent match on the show, and very little that was memorable.

I think in terms of quality of the show and long term implications this Mania will rank with 3/14/17 as the best of the best.

 

[Kill Dat Noize]

No love for WM6?

Easily one of the best of all time.

The roster in 1990 was the best roster of all time

- Hogan
- Warrior
- Andre
- Savage
- Piper
- Rude
- Perfect
- Jake
- DiBiase
- Dusty
- Hart Foundation (Bret)
- Demolition
- Rockers (Shawn)
- Snuka
- Martel

90 had the best rumble too.

90% of that list are first ballot hofers and/or all time greats.

 

[I-Hate-You]

Three legit all-time moments: Austin/Rock/Hulk, Streak Ends, Bryan Wins
Bray/Cena, Cesaro Breaks Out, HHH/Bryan

Wish the Shield would have had a bigger moment and the Taker match would have been a little better...but this was a great show.

 

[Kidd Dibiase]

How nobody got WM18 up there

 

[FakeNews]

Wrestlemania 15 was ass....one of the worst of all time. That was the height of Russo booking....there was like one decent match on the show, and very little that was memorable.

I think in terms of quality of the show and long term implications this Mania will rank with 3/14/17 as the best of the best.

I have to agree I hated WM 15. Outside of Austin v. Rock I can't even remember any memorable matches from WM 15

My personal favorite Manias are 3,8,10,14,17,19,30

 

[CM_Burns]

Top 10, same level as 24 and 26. I can't believe how bad Brock/Taker was and it sucks that the streak ends on that type of match after the last few streak matches, but otherwise I was enjoying the show the whole time. Divas match was funny how little people cared and were chanting Taker, Shield match at least kept my attention. Cena/Wyatt and the Battle Royal started off boring but got very good. The opener, and especially the triforce of GOATs and main event were great.

 

[R=G]

WM 17 is the greatest. ....WM 19 was very good....WM 28 was a great spectacle...this was very entertaining.

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

WM14 wasn't good either. It's remembered fondly because of Austin and the start of the Attitude Era but there's a lot of bullshyt on that show.

 

[The G.O.D II]

I would put it outside the top ten. Definitely the best Mania since 24 though. Bryan really saved this show though.

1)17
2)8
3)19
4)3
5)7
6)20
7)10
8)23
9)6
10)21