So we're gonna act like Aaron Rodgers came into the NFL with no development? Didn't McCarthy make it to the NFC championship before rodgers? Are u seriously questioning McCarthy resume?
Top 5 active coaches not named beli
- Thread starter Ronald McDonald
- Start date
dora_da_destroyer
Master Baker
Making it to the conference title isn't necessarily indicative of being one of the top 5 football minds/coaches, development also isn't, a lot goes into that, Rodgers specifically benefitted from coaching continuity and sitting behind a future HOFer in Favre ...mccarthy was a legit OC....but yes, i question putting him as top 5. He's also one of the few coaches that didn't have to deal with QB woes, went from Favre to Rodgers...very few coaches get to transition like that. I asked you a legit question as to why you put him there...yet you're getting defensive. I've also seen him outcoached on multiple occasions. None of this means he isn't good at his job, but I don't see him as top 5
OK, since I've already made my list. Let me see your top 5 first to see if it's worth my time going in depth.Making it to the conference title isn't necessarily indicative of being one of the top 5 football minds/coaches, development also isn't, a lot goes into that, Rodgers specifically benefitted from coaching continuity and sitting behind a future HOFer in Favre ...mccarthy was a legit OC....but yes, i question putting him as top 5. He's also one of the few coaches that didn't have to deal with QB woes, went from Favre to Rodgers...very few coaches get to transition like that. I asked you a legit question as to why you put him there...yet you're getting defensive. I've also seen him outcoached on multiple occasions. None of this means he isn't good at his job, but I don't see him as top 5
