Top 5 Receivers In The League?

[Trip]

So what happened in 2010 and in 2011 before Tebow took over?

Rookie seasons, which are generally washes for WR's and he was battling injuries. He came back for the VIkings game in 2011 and played very well.

 

[Brozay]

1. Megatron
2. AJ
3. Julio
4. Roddy
5. Fitz

What makes Roddy better than AJ Green or BMarsh?

 

[HarlemsOwn]

@Trip look how im bout to make you look foolish.....

If Jay Cutler was targeting Calvin Johnson, Demaryius Thomas, AJ Green, or Dez Bryant- they'd be putting up even better numbers, with better catch rates. That's why he's overated...he isnt as good as the elite guys yet puts up gaudy numbers. You cant look at these guys in a vacuum.

Calvin Had the most targets in the league

is he overated?

AJ Green was 5ht

 

[Trip]

@Trip look how im bout to make you look foolish.....



Calvin Had the most targets in the league

is he overated?

AJ Green was 5ht

when did I say targets were a bad?

 

[Buckeye Fever]

Mega
Fitz
AJ
Julio
Ginn

 

[HarlemsOwn]

when did I say targets were a bad?

from what i understand you was sayin that Brandon Marshall is overrated. his stats are high because he was targeted the most. and you said that if calvin and AJ and others were targeted as much as Brandon then they would have better stats and all that

 

[HarlemsOwn]

What makes Roddy better than AJ Green or BMarsh?

he from atlanta prolly

he obviously bias

 

[The ADD]

Mega
Fitz
AJ
Julio
Ginn

 

[AVXL]

What makes Roddy better than AJ Green or BMarsh?

I meant AJ Green. Roddy's got more consistent hands than Brandon & more consistent numbers (6 straight seasons of 80 plus catches and at least 1100 yards receiving). Brandon's good though, he's #6 on my list

 

[I'm Chillin]

1. Calvin Johnson
2. Dez
3. AJ Green
4. Brandon Marshall
5. Fitzgerald

 

[Trip]

from what i understand you was sayin that Brandon Marshall is overrated. his stats are high because he was targeted the most. and you said that if calvin and AJ and others were targeted as much as Brandon then they would have better stats and all that

Calvin and Dez both had better catch rates when compared to times targeted. You put a player like Dez in an offense with Cutler throwing you the ball at that rate, you'll see even more production. On the surface Marshall had a better season than Dez did, but outside the vacuum...Dez was actually the better player.

 

[Brozay]

I meant AJ Green. Roddy's got more consistent hands than Brandon & more consistent numbers (6 straight seasons of 80 plus catches and at least 1100 yards receiving). Brandon's good though, he's #6 on my list

OK. So Roddy is better than Andre Johnson & Dez Byrant? Really?

Roddy aint top 5 no more. Sorry.

 

[G.O.A.T]

Yup and Dez, B Marsh, Jones (GB) after that....

James Jones should not be mention on that list

 

[YouMadd?]

James Jones should not be mention on that list

Well I just did... He is a top 10 receiver in the league in my opinion... What are you gonna do about it ?

 

[Brozay]

Calvin and Dez both had better catch rates when compared to times targeted. You put a player like Dez in an offense with Cutler throwing you the ball at that rate, you'll see even more production. On the surface Marshall had a better season than Dez did, but outside the vacuum...Dez was actually the better player.

Im assuming they have nothing that differentiates the quality of targets? Cutler forcing every ball Bmarsh's way because hes an idiot and also has no other options shouldnt take away from Marshalls value. No?