Top 5 Receivers In The League?

[Filluminati]

for all i care AJ is top 3 AT LEAST.

 

[Trip]

Im assuming they have nothing that differentiates the quality of targets? Cutler forcing every ball Bmarsh's way because hes an idiot and also has no other options shouldnt take away from Marshalls value. No?

DYAR, or Defense-adjusted Yards Above Replacement. This gives the value of the performance on plays where this WR caught the ball, compared to replacement level, adjusted for situation and opponent and then translated into yardage. D

• We cannot yet fully separate the performance of a receiver from the performance of his quarterback. Be aware that one will affect the other.

fwiw

 

[AVXL]

OK. So Roddy is better than Andre Johnson & Dez Byrant? Really?

Roddy aint top 5 no more. Sorry.

Andre is always hurt though...and only had 4 TDs last yr.

How often does Dez run the wrong route or not complete a route that leads to a Romo or pick or incomplete pass? Look beyond the stats brehs

 

[Trip]

Honestly TD's arent a great indicator of a WR's effectiveness

 

[Primetime21]

How often does Dez run the wrong route or not complete a route that leads to a Romo or pick or incomplete pass?

You talking about shyt you saw his first 2 years instead of what you saw the last half of last year Garrett would go entire halves without calling his number and he still beasted. Imagine if he got the same treatment as your sweeties

 

[RiffRaff]

I don't know about right now but that boy Kenny Britt gonna be top 5 after this year

 

[Spaceman Piff]

1. calvin
2. aj
3. dez
4. demaryius
5. bmarsh

julio's outside because he's not the #1 guy yet.

 

[AVXL]

You talking about shyt you saw his first 2 years instead of what you saw the last half of last year

So we go off of half seasons now?

Dez is still undisciplined in his routes, he's a top 10 WR, but Roddy out there running precision routes plus giving you outstanding production. I don't see why it's bias to claim that the Falcons have 2 of the top 5 WR in the league

 

[Trip]

Vincent Jackson, Roddy White, Fitzgerald, Welker, Cruz, Nicks all honorable mention. And too bad Crabtree got hurt.

 

[Primetime21]

So we go off of half seasons now?

Dez is still undisciplined in his routes, he's a top 10 WR, but Roddy out there running precision routes plus giving you outstanding production. I don't see why it's bias to claim that the Falcons have 2 of the top 5 WR in the league

When did I say it was bias I just said Dez is better than both of them

 

[Born2BKing]

Rookie seasons, which are generally washes for WR's and he was battling injuries. He came back for the VIkings game in 2011 and played very well.

Trip think about this, do you think there is an NFL team Peyton Manning could go to and not have a 1000 yard receiver who could be pro bowl worthy?

 

[Trip]

Trip think about this, do you think there is an NFL team Peyton Manning could go to and not have a 1000 yard receiver who could be pro bowl worthy?

Of course, Manning is that good. But separate the two for a second, put Thomas' year into context, the plays he made down the field and after the catch- the kid is a stud regardless of QB play. He was second in the league with 29 catches over 20 yards or more and 4th in YAC.

 

[AVXL]

When did I say it was bias I just said Dez is better than both of them

That's fine. That's your opinion & I have mine. I disagree with you though, Roddy's a top 5 WR, Dez isnt

 

[Primetime21]

That's fine. That's your opinion & I have mine. I disagree with you though, Roddy's a top 5 WR, Dez isnt

That's fine, we'll revisit this post before this season is over.

 

[Born2BKing]

Of course, Manning is that good. But separate the two for a second, put Thomas' year into context, the plays he made down the field and after the catch- the kid is a stud regardless of QB play. He was second in the league with 29 catches over 20 yards or more and 4th in YAC.

He is a good player breh but I cannot put him in the top 5 yet, definitely not top 4. Hell Eric Decker had 1000 yards last season