The Source was a really good magazine for a very long time. They were the hiphop main source for new artists, established artists, interviews, reviews and even good articles just about the Black community. They also promoted a very wide spectrum of hip hop, from the most commercial to the most underground. They are the reason we still use a mic rating system for hiphop albums.
They held it down during the 90 along with Vibe, but Vibe leaned more to RnB.
The beef with Eminem was dumb and did fukk up their reputation a little, along with the Lil Kim 5 mic review and the Made Men 4.5 mic review.
XXL was a decent fill in but they was never really as good as The Source at its peak.
The biggest problem with The Source is really they failed to transition to digital media. I know they had a website but it wasn’t good and other better sites passed it up.
All Facts - not to mention the Political caricatures for the last page for the cover artist and The Boondocks strip, and Star & Buckwild all were in The Source.
Honestly, even if they got the hang of digital media...which still wouldn't have been as effective, they definitely fail in the video driven era. The one thing I loved about their articles is that they were focused on a specific narrative, and the interview with said artist all pinpointed that. If it was an upcoming album, the article was about the recording process, the rollout, the state of mind of the artist, and anything else circulating around it. It never went off on a tangent. If it was turmoil, it was how did it get this bad. If it was a breakup, why and can it be resolved. They also describe the scenery, the body language and tone of interviewee, and if necessary, the run around the interviewee gave them. They made sure to point out they had to speak to 7 people to have a sit down, just to convey the status of said person. They were great journalists, and probably