That's it, the problem was never him not knowing shyt or making mistakes, it was the attitude of superiority and acting like an infallible all knowledgeable dude on Hip Hop when that's far from the case. I peeped he was a fraud very early because he couldn't back up what he said and tried to play semantics with the more dense posters he thought he could get away with it with, but when people with knowledge that were articulate challenged him he exposed what a complete fraud he was by deflecting and merely insulting people rather than debating or discussing the issues. It was never where he's from, him being gay, or even him hearing Illmatic or whatever mad late, it was the incessant lying and putting up the fraudulent persona which is why this happened.
I spoke to him civilly and politely at first and tried to see where he was coming from and discuss and debate but because he couldn't try the dumb shyt or win the debate he tried to deflect with bullshyt. He was portraying a persona that isn't him, if he wasn't none of this would have happened. It's self destructive really, cause if he got into the shyt late or whatever he could have learnt from some people on here instead of acting like he was somehow inherently superior to them. Everyone is entitled to their opinions, agree or disagree but when you don't know what you're talking about it's better to be humble. There were massive gaping holes in his knowledge, even of high profile artists or legends, not just regional or underground shyt, he wasn't the head he made out to be and clearly has issues with seeking attention.
He was a bit of a Hipster clown, like you said parroting shyt he's read or heard, when you read and see what he's written it is MAD corny and he's completely oblivious to the culture or even in depth of the genre, he's been introduced to a few things but has massive gaping holes in his knowledge but wants to act like an expert. We all don't know everything, but he is ignorant about shyt you really really should know, and if you don't you should be humble and learn before you try to act high and mighty.
AllHipHop? Lol. Yeah I was even on there too BACK in the day lol, was very young back them, remember some of the posters like HipHopScribe, BigDennis who I believe still posts here, Deadazz who HATED Eminem with a passion lol, and mad others lol. SirBiatch round that time was thinking Biggie was sampling Ashanti lol... Respect to you anyway. Peace.