Bigwhite2498
Superstar
What is this Bijan slander
What RB would you rather have? Gibbs or James Cook
- Thread starter Alvin
- Start date
DetroitEWarren
Veteran
He would have broke the record and been an MVP candidate if he didn't share carries with Montgomery.
Piff Perkins
Veteran
Virtually the same rushing yards despite Gibbs having 50 less carries. 5.6 yards per rush compared to Bijan's 4.8. Gibbs a better receiving back too.
Bigwhite2498
Superstar
Bijan has a far worse offensive line tho and has to deal with teams knowing Kirk bum ass couldn’t do anything most of the season
Piff Perkins
Veteran
Fair enough. I think they're both elite, Bijan is #4 to me. I honestly think Gibbs would have put him Saquon-type numbers if he wasn't in a near 50/50 snap split. The Lions keep both guys fresh and healthy which is smart but that split should be more 60/40 next season.
Bigwhite2498
Superstar
I agree both are elite I personally just feel like if bijan had that oline and skill around him he would be challenging Barkley for the throne. Hes never gotten to actually play with elite talent in the nfl or college
Bboystyle
Bang Bang Packers gang!
Jacobs >>>My brother in Christ, Gibbs is at least RB3 in the league. Only behind Saquon and Henry.
Gibbs stats only look good because DET was pass first offense most the year which is why he only got 250 touches and it helped open the run game. Put Gibbs on a run first team and he wont last or be up there with Saquon, Henry and Jacobs. 100%
Piff Perkins
Veteran
Jacobs >>>
Gibbs stats only look good because DET was pass first offense most the year. Put Gibbs on a run first team and he wont last
1. Saquon
2. Barkley
3. Gibbs
4. Bijan
5. Jacobs
Detroit runs more than most teams lmao
Bboystyle
Bang Bang Packers gang!
Lions fans deluisional like always. jacobs carried the packers offense. Gibbs didnt. He benefited from one
J-MIL
Fly Sh!t Only
Gibbs it's not even close