Warren Peace
Superstar
Me personally, I think 5 is where it started slumping a bit.
When do you think Game of Thrones started going downhill?
- Thread starter Warren Peace
- Start date
-
- Tags
- game of thrones hbo
Erratic415
Superstar
Season 5.
1-4 were amazing. 5 and 6 were more up and down. Still enjoyable to me, but clearly a step down in writing and storytelling. 7 and especially 8 were just rushed messes.
1-4 were amazing. 5 and 6 were more up and down. Still enjoyable to me, but clearly a step down in writing and storytelling. 7 and especially 8 were just rushed messes.
KevCo
Bond's gun spoke once....
5 but i thought six was a good bounce back and ended with two top 5 episodes. So ill just say 7 was when it was all falling apart…but at the time i thought it was cause 8 would be the most epic shyt ever…and then 8 happened
The Wolf Among You
Superstar
I enjoyed it all the way through. Only thing I didn't like was the Agenda shyt they threw in season 4-5 ish(can't remember) and when they suddently decided to make Arya a warrior goddess and Sansa General Patton.
I did think the finale was dumb, the idea that Bran was emperor-worthy was goofy. He was a space cadet by then.
I did think the finale was dumb, the idea that Bran was emperor-worthy was goofy. He was a space cadet by then.
Avisible Man
S/N: 52093850
George R. R. said that the show passed his books towards the end of season 5. The funny thing is that only the final 3 episodes of season 5 had ratings of 9+ on IMDb, starting with Hardhome.
There were still 3 All Time episodes in season 6: The Door, Battle of the b*stards and The Winds if Winter. The highs were the highest they could be but that consistent output could not be maintained.
There were still 3 All Time episodes in season 6: The Door, Battle of the b*stards and The Winds if Winter. The highs were the highest they could be but that consistent output could not be maintained.
MacNCheese
All Star
When they started running out of ASOIAF material, so like mid season 5. Around the time Jamie and Bronn snuck into Dorne is when I started noticing a drop in quality.
This line in particular is when it got real, real noticeable.
thefloorislava
All Star
MenacingMonk
War & Peace
When Holdor stood for “hold the door.” 
I was entertained by the show tho.
I was entertained by the show tho.
Warren Peace
Superstar
Pull Up the Roots
Veteran
Season 5.
Cersei empowering the religious nuts made no sense to me. The Sons of the Harpy plot was nonsensical. And the less said about Stannis and his fall the better.
Cersei empowering the religious nuts made no sense to me. The Sons of the Harpy plot was nonsensical. And the less said about Stannis and his fall the better.
Professor K.
rap game Paul Millsap
I think I knew the show was done when Coldhands shows up out of nowhere to save Jon at the frozen lake and then is never mentioned again 