Where Does Donovan McSwagg rank on All-Time Black QB List?

[Red Money]

He gotta be top 10, right?


Don of them McSwagg threw a few too many dirt balls....but if Lamar Jackson always needs more helps then McSwagg needed miracle help for his pass catching core outside of that TO Superbowl run year.


Todd Pinkston, Freddie Mitchell, James Thrash....NFL fans know them for being frustrating players holding the McSwagg era Eagles back from getting over the hump.

 

[Mandizi]

Easily a top 10 black nfl QB ever.

 

[AlbertPullhoez]

Underrated and catches way more shyt than he deserves

I do wish he hadn't stopped running and using his legs as often though. It's like dude was dead set on proving he was a pocket passer

 

[manyfaces]

You forgot the silent "b", C'mon Son

 

[GR13]

He gotta be top 10, right?


Don of them McSwagg threw a few too many dirt balls....

the dirtballs /worm burner criticism was always overblown with McNabb when you take into account the he had the best TD to INT ratio of his era yes a era that included Brady, Bress , Manning, it was McNabb that had the best TD to INT ratio of the decade

best believe if it was Eli Manning that had a tendency to miss low and not high like most other Qbs but had a elite Td to INT ratio he would get praised for missing throws low and not high by cac announcer's missing throw's low would be seen as almost a built-in positive part of his game and they would always make sure to let it be known he was the best at not throwing/avoiding int

after all a few dirtballs don't stop Josh Allen from being Jesus, Thor, Paul Bunyan all rolled in one

 

[Mike18jj]

Might be top 5ish

If we going off accomplishments Mahomes, then Lamar, then everyone else


off the top of my head Mahomes, Lamar, Warren Moon, Russ, Air Mcnair , Mcnabb, Cam , Vick, Randall Cunningham, Daunte Culpepper no order

 

[FTBS]

Top 10?

Mahomes obviously.
Lamar if we going off accolades. Although McNabb, despite his unfair rep was a superior playoff performer.
Not sure there is a inarguable case for putting anyone else over him.

 

[Red Money]

Might be top 5ish

If we going off accomplishments Mahomes, then Lamar, then everyone else


off the top of my head Mahomes, Lamar, Warren Moon, Russ, Air Mcnair , Mcnabb, Cam , Vick, Randall Cunningham, Daunte Culpepper no order

Cunningham ....if he were on these Chiefs instead of Mahomes he is getting rings as well barring injury.

Cunningham got injured as he was hitting the peak of his powers... Cunningham would have been a force for the entire 90s if he was healthy. Who is Brett Favre and Steve Young in a world in which Cunningham is healthy the entire 90s?...hmmmm....

 

[Professor K.]

Underrated and catches way more shyt than he deserves

I do wish he hadn't stopped running and using his legs as often though. It's like dude was dead set on proving he was a pocket passer

He did that shyt directly in response to Rush Limbaugh. He let that cac make him change his game for the worse to try to prove a point instead of saying fukk that shyt and doing him. I never liked him as a kid because of that shyt

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

Donofthem McSwaggb

 

[L $ C]

top 10? easily...if he had a ship he'd be remembered totally diff...guy was great for a long time

 

[Reggie]

Moon. Randall. Cam. Lamar. McNair. Wilson. Don't know anyone else (unless I'm just not thinking clearly right now) except maybe Vick ahead of him and I'm not sure about that or McNair. Not counting Pat cause he's mixed or obviously he would be number 1.

 

[yseJ]

@CantStop

 

[manyfaces]

Donofthem McSwaggb

A top 10 SOHH/Coli nickname for sure

 

[Leonard Washington]

how u forget the silent b?