Where would you rank ARod all time?

[Da_Eggman]

nobody hates the Yankees and Arod more than me but it is kinda sad that everything he did as a player will just be brushed aside at one point many thought he would easily break all the records

its crazy to think after Bonds broke the hr record many though "well thankfully arod will come and break his record and return the honor of the record"

but they cant take away his stats or his awards i still see him as the 3rd best player of the juiced era behind Bonds and Griffey

and at-least a top 10 SS

 

[jadillac]

nobody hates the Yankees and Arod more than me but it is kinda sad that everything he did as a player will just be brushed aside at one point many thought he would easily break all the records

its crazy to think after Bonds broke the hr record many though "well thankfully arod will come and break his record and return the honor of the record"

LOL.....I remember that talk.

Meanwhile Arod was like, "here's a little twist for you, turns out I been cheatin too"

 

[T.he I.nformant]

He doesn't deserve to be mentioned among the greats

 

[Da_Eggman]

it really was

"fukk that cheating ass bonds has the record"

"nah its cool Arod is on pace for like 800 homers"



now

"maybe stanton or harper in 20 years will break it"

 

[Da_Eggman]

He doesn't deserve to be mentioned among the greats

let me hear your top ten SS just for reference

 

[nomoreneveragain]

He's been roiding since he was a H.S QB

 

[T.he I.nformant]

let me hear your top ten SS just for reference

Purely off principle that A-Rod is not on my list. If you're going by stats only, the nikka obviously deserves a spot. shyt ain't just stats, though. In particular, the PED scandals vex me. Can't put A-Rod next to Jeter, Ozzie, Cal, etc. knowing that the nikka is a fukking fraud. Just don't feel right. Seems disrespectful to the nikkas that have done it the legit way. Maybe I'll feel differently some day.

 

[Bilz]

Biggest fakkit in MLB history

 

[Taadow]

#5 Ranger
#5 Mariner
Top-75 Yankee
Barely Top-20 Baseball Cheater
Top 10 Punchable Face

 

[Jax]

 

[Captain Crunch]

Best SS of the last 70+ years, if not ever.

 

[Jax]

Best SS of the last 70+ years, if not ever.

 

[Brown Ant]

Top 5 dead or alive.

 

[feelosofer]

Cheating has been a part of baseball since time immemorial. Corked bats, spitting on balls whatever.

A-Rod is top 25 player of all time and def the greatest shortstop of the past 50 years outside of Derek Jeter.

Baseball suspends the dude and at 38, you got the Yankees begging dude to play, since he is still the best offensive player, and best hitter on their team.

Scust.

And I'm a Mets fan saying this.

 

[Captain Crunch]

Best hitting shortstop ever. When he was a SS, he was miles better than Jeter and NoMar, he was a superstar along with Griffey and Bonds.