Who brought out the best in Aaliyah? Timbaland or R. Kelly?

jadillac

Veteran
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
57,228
Reputation
9,570
Daps
176,754
R. Kelly barely worked with her in terms of output.

Timbaland and her were a great unique combo. She wasn't a powerful singer, but her voice was absolutely perfect for those productions.
 

African Peasant

Veteran
Joined
Oct 18, 2014
Messages
21,611
Reputation
3,789
Daps
79,025
Kellz
Keep it mind Kellz had her when she was very young.

But I listen to Kellz stuff more. Timbaland shyt was nice but some it is dated.

Her best songs are wikth Kellz

He first album is her only classic.

Her last album was mid



>>>>>>>
 
Last edited:

O.Red

Veteran
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
19,533
Reputation
6,314
Daps
78,763
Reppin
NULL
Timbaland easy

The Timbaland/Aaliyah/Missy style of r&b is still being chased to this day

80% of female(you can probably add male honestly) r&b in the last 15 years have been variations of One In A Million and 4 Page Letter
 

African Peasant

Veteran
Joined
Oct 18, 2014
Messages
21,611
Reputation
3,789
Daps
79,025
Timbaland easy

The Timbaland/Aaliyah/Missy style of r&b is still being chased to this day

80% of female(you can probably add male honestly) r&b in the last 15 years have been variations of One In A Million and 4 Page Letter
Cause it's easier to do...

Unless you claim it was the best type of Rnb out there, which is not true.

R Kelly/Babyface RnB >>>> Timbo/Missy RnB
 

O.Red

Veteran
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
19,533
Reputation
6,314
Daps
78,763
Reppin
NULL
Cause it's easier to do...

Unless you claim it was the best type of Rnb out there, which is not true.

R Kelly/Babyface RnB >>>> Timbo/Missy RnB
That doesn't negate how good it was. That's like invalidating Kobe because everyone copied his moves

I have no problem calling R Kelly the GOAT but that doesn't also mean he brought the best out of Aaliyah
 

TheDarkCloud

Superstar
Joined
Mar 18, 2017
Messages
5,569
Reputation
1,457
Daps
22,541
Kellz
Keep it mind Kellz had her when she was very young.

But I listen to Kellz stuff more. Timbaland shyt was nice but some it is dated.

Her best songs are wikth Kellz

He first album is her only classic.

Her last album was mid



>>>>>>>

One In A Million is definitely a classic, tho. That joint changed the game.
 

African Peasant

Veteran
Joined
Oct 18, 2014
Messages
21,611
Reputation
3,789
Daps
79,025
That doesn't negate how good it was. That's like invalidating Kobe because everyone copied his moves

I have no problem calling R Kelly the GOAT but that doesn't also mean he brought the best out of Aaliyah
I'm not invalidating the Aaliyah Timbo sound. It was good. Very good.

however, it copied because it's easier to do for all these mid singers and it was more in line with the b*stardization of RnB.
 

African Peasant

Veteran
Joined
Oct 18, 2014
Messages
21,611
Reputation
3,789
Daps
79,025
One In A Million is definitely a classic, tho. That joint changed the game.
Aaliyah was clearly more succesful, more iconic with Timbo.

But the music she did with Kellz was a lil bit better. Just little, not much.

I also think she would've reached the same level of success with Kelz. It was just a matter of time.

Aaliyah had that IT factor. She was just too young (no :sitdown:) when she was with Kelz
 
Top