Who has the better legacy: Donovan McNabb or Mike Vick?

[kash10003]

Vick don't got Mcnabb's passing numbers, yards or wins. But Mcnabb got the numbers and TD's with his feet just like Vick does.

you tryna say mcnabb wasn't a great passing QB in his time breh? He has better passing #s than Jim Kelly.

 

[J Money]

McNabb easily.

But Vick will ALWAYS be my boy for leading the Miracle

 

[Rapmastermind]

you tryna say mcnabb wasn't a great passing QB in his time breh? He has better passing #s than Jim Kelly.

No I'm saying Mcnabb is a more complete QB than Vick cause he has the passing, yards and rushing yards and TD's where as Vick is mostly rushing yards and TD's. Not saying Vick can't pass cause he has a bullett arm but Mcnabb was more accurate. Also Mcnabb has one of the best INT ratio's in NFL History. Mcnabb didn't throw terrible picks like Vick did. It was always a blue moon when Mcnabb threw an awful Pick. Vick seemed to throw a bad pick every game. Or Fumble. Vick fumbles a lot.

 

[kash10003]

look at my nikka scramble, shed flabby cowboys defenders, on all the dallas players and cheerleders, eat some chunky soup, drop an accurate long pass to bum ass freddie mitchell

 

[Rapmastermind]

When Donovan threw this pass I thought we were going back to the Super Bowl. Arizona played hard but Philly VS Pittsburgh would of been so EPIC:

 

[Tha Gawd Amen]

Outside of TO, who was Prime McNabb's best WR? Kevin Curtis, Freddie Mitchell, or James Thrash

 

[IAmGettingAMailOrderBride]

Donovan was as good a kurt warner

 

[WaddupDoe!]

McNabb better legacy. But Vick has more highlights in his career.

 

[SAJ!!]

Donovan.

 

[Captain Crunch]

When Donovan threw this pass I thought we were going back to the Super Bowl. Arizona played hard but Philly VS Pittsburgh would of been so EPIC:

I was so tight they didn't win, I thought it was finally McNabb's year

 

[NYSTATEOFMIND]

Two of my favorite QB's ever. Who has the better legacy?

Mak you one of the cooler posters but

Eagles never won any playoff games with Vick...Mcribb at least got us to 5 NFC Champ games and 3 of them with no WR talent to speak of

 

[NYSTATEOFMIND]

Easily Vick

-First black QB drafted #1 overall - what does that prove
-Best running QB ever- then be a running back- non accurate throwing motherfukker
-Ridiculous highlights- and...
-Madden- what the eff that gotta do with real life
-Real nikka- and.......
-Smokes weed- so does every other player
-Served time- u cant be serious
-2 separate $100 million deals- just means the teams dont manage money well
-2010... oh 2010
-Flicked off fans, lied to the commissioner's face, gave no fukks



I can't think of a QB I'd wanna go to battle with more.

Vick aint shyt...this aint a video game..

 

[NYSTATEOFMIND]

white's will say mcnabb

black's will say vick


im black so u know who im rolling with

im black ..and im riding with Donovan Mcpuke...Vick is one of the most overrated players I have ever seen...

 

[NYSTATEOFMIND]

Outside of TO, who was Prime McNabb's best WR? Kevin Curtis, Freddie Mitchell, or James Thrash

exactly!!! I always argued that point..bc everyone white and black used to trash Donovan..he was my guy...even tho he was corny as fukk and he loved throwing worm burners ( balls at ya feet) I think if he has the WR talent Vick has been afforded...he would have seen a few more SB appearances

 

[Jesus Shuttlesworth]

Vick aint shyt...this aint a video game..

It's bigger than football. You embarrass all black people with this blasphemy.