Who has the higher ceiling: Kyrie Irving or John Wall?

Toe Jay Simpson

Searchin’
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
27,434
Reputation
10,110
Daps
147,100
Reppin
Carmel City
I see Wall being just another one of those naturally gifted athletes who just gets by on what's capable of doing for the moment and ends up becoming :flabbynsick: mid career

Irving's drive is gonna take him so much further
 

mastermind

Rest In Power Kobe
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
65,587
Reputation
6,544
Daps
175,387
Same here. I was concerned too. But he clearly has been watching film and being on the bench also gave him the time to observe the game from the coach's angle.

yeah, there was an article in the New York Times over the weekend that talked about how Wall took a step back and started studying the game more.

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/10/s...has-wizards-thinking-about-playoffs.html?_r=0


and of course there is this from Stackhouse :russ:

Jerry Stackhouse, the Nets’ 38-year-old swingman, has become something of a mentor to Wall. They grew up in the same region of North Carolina and developed a close relationship in 2010 as teammates in a summer pro-am league that Stackhouse runs in Raleigh. But their relationship did not blossom overnight. Wall, who was a rookie at the time, seemed eager to showcase his talent. Stackhouse was not particularly impressed.

“He was coming down every time, forcing shots, nobody else touching the ball — and his teammates were wide open,” said Stackhouse, one of those teammates. “I was like, ‘You have got to move the basketball.’ He got a little upset and said something back to me.”

Stackhouse added, “I was like, ‘Who do you think you’re talking to?’ ”

Stackhouse woulda fukked Wall up. :laugh:
 

Basaglia

All Star
Joined
May 22, 2012
Messages
1,806
Reputation
393
Daps
3,268
Reppin
No
Let me explain something about a jump shot:

you can take a good one and make it great. (nash, paul...billups to a lesser extent)

you can *improve* an AWFUL one. (gary payton, avery)

you CANNOT "get" a good one. (anyone still waiting on rondo's to come around?)

the basic mechanics of his shot are disgusting. it's a push shot that starts off his shoulder. he been shooting that way since he was 11 or 12 i bet. it's over and done with. he not gettin a "good" jumper. he gonna always be a sub 45%, sub-35% from three player.

so, y'all can keep hemming and hawing and iffin and buttin about some theoretical jumper. it ain't gonna change the facts...

kyrie at 24, 6 and 4 and an all-star at 20.

wall averages 8 dimes and sporting a 3FG% that looks like it could be angela bassett's...at 22.

i'd be less offended by ty lawson or mike conley being cysed over kyrie. but, they don't jump high enough, i guess.

and this whole thread is offensive to jrue holiday. i'm offended for jrue and his fans.
 

FAH1223

Go Wizards, Go Terps, Go Packers!
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
80,823
Reputation
10,079
Daps
238,508
Reppin
WASHINGTON, DC

Diyhai

En Causa Sui
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
14,178
Reputation
753
Daps
20,139
Reppin
Baltimore
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
1,368
Reputation
-60
Daps
1,589
walls athleticism dwarfs kyries...and he is the better defender
john has the higher ceiling but will he reach it? that has yet to be seen.
he's been in the league 3 years and still has a broken ass jumper.

this is a myth
Kyrie is every bit as quick on offense as John Wall..and john wall's bounce is overrated
 

Basaglia

All Star
Joined
May 22, 2012
Messages
1,806
Reputation
393
Daps
3,268
Reppin
No
Wall has Gary Payton level of potential, I doubt he reaches it though.

Kyrie doesn't have as much potential, but he's much more likely to reach his ceiling than Wall.

Kyrie's max is far beyond Gary Payton. By the time Kyrie is 24 (the age payton was when he finally put it all together) and has a solid team around him, you looking at something like 22-25ppg, 7-10 apg, and 4 boards...depending on what they need from him. he can give you that for the next 12 years...easy.

while y'all still talkin about wall fixin a BASIC JUMP SHOT, kyrie has added...

a post game, complete with a fade J

a lefty floater

a euro step, only surpassed by wade, harden and manu

a pull-up 12, 15, 18 and 20 footer

and he's improved his defense.


a player's "ceiling" is his projected maximum productivity based on his intrinsic skillsets and physical gifts.

some of you base ceilings ENTIRELY on physical gifts. and then you limit those physical gifts to speed, power and leaping ability. agility is thrown out the window. endurance? out the window. hand-eye coordination? don't even matter.

FWIW, agility and hand-eye is why kyrie finishes better than wall and every other jumpin jack. the ability the square up to the basket at odd angles and apply just the right amount of spin and touch on layups over big azz humans ain't something that can just be "DEVELOPED." like, "oh...i'll just practice that. it'll be fine" you either got it or you don't. wall ain't got that or a jump shot or elite change of direction handles.

next season, if john wall can do what jrue holiday is doing NOW, then this is a legit convo. jrue a 19 and 9 all-star.

as it stands, it's just some dudes who been waiting for their guy to get back and cysed off a 9-7 "hot streak" (led mostly by two 30 year-old bigs who tryna get traded, by the way...but give wall all the credit) by a team hellbent on playin themselves out of top 8 pick.
 

GoldenGlove

😐😑😶😑😐
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
61,628
Reputation
6,081
Daps
145,303
I question the level of discussion in here because I doubt many people in here are watching Wizards and Cavs games unless they're in Cleveland or DC. If you don't have League Pass, I doubt you know enough to pick one or the other...

With that being said:

John Wall has the higher ceiling.

I see Wall's peak as being an elite defender at his position (he's already damn good) and just a great overall PG. He won't be able to hit that jumper like Kyrie, and he won't be able to score like him... but if Wall gets some consistently with his J, he'll really be tough to guard. Teams sag off of him and he still finds ways to get to the rim and get to the FT line.

Wall is already really good with a lot of things to work on, Kyrie is more polished and is already in the ASG... how much better is he going to get though?
 
Top