Who is the GOAT Black Quarterback?

[Reggie]

Moon by a mile. He was the best and I would like to see what his numbers would have looked like if he played his whole career in the NFL. He probably would be sitting on 400 touchdowns and 70000 yards.

 

[SubZeroDegrees]

1) Warren Moon
2) Steve McNair
3) Donovan McNabb
4) Randall Cunningham
5) Doug Williams

I agree.

 

[Dr. Narcisse]

Moon.

Could have been McNabb but he choked away so many games.

Culpepper would have a better legacy if he didnt get hurt.

If Cunningham played for an offensive minded coach he would be a HOF.

Cam has the most potential..

Vick should have been one of if not the greatest ever...

 

[Benjamin Sisko]

No mentions of Vick?

This. It took too long for someone to mention him.

No other recent player, regardless of his position, had a bigger impact in the NFL then Michael Muhommed Vick. Remember he was the player that gave opposing DC's nightmares because of his speed and arm. He transformed the Falcons overnight. Michael Vick was gonna recolutionized the position and the NFL if he didnt fukked up. I think it was some type of set up though.

 

[Harry Sax]

Jameis Winston

 

[JLova]

Off the top..... Moon, McNabb, McNair, Cunningham....

Then there's a massive drop off.

 

[JLova]

This. It took too long for someone to mention him.

No other recent player, regardless of his position, had a bigger impact in the NFL then Michael Muhommed Vick. Remember he was the player that opposing DC's gave nightmares because of his speed and arm. He transformed the Falcons overnight. Michael Vick was gonna recolutionized the position and the NFL if he didnt fukked up. I think it was some type of set up though.

Vick was electrifying and took the league by storm, but he should be nowhere near this discussion.

 

[Digga38]

Warren Moon. Had to spend 6 yrs in Canada
5 Grey Cups (Canadian Super Bowl)

9x Pro Bowler

If it wasnt for cacism he would be in the conversation for GOAT hands down because thats another 6 yrs of NFL Stats

In the GOAT discussion? No. 3-7 in the playoffs. Never made it past the 2nd round. Lost to some teams they were favored against like the Chiefs with Montana and the Bills when they came back from 35-3 with a backup QB in.

one could conclude the competition in the cfl < nfl
imagine if he was rightly drafted in the nfl to start...would he have not have been a even better player

see how the white man robbed us again

one of the all time travesty i ever seen....

i think it would have been a lock for him to have a super bowl ring if he had those 6 years

 

[Schmoove]

Doug Williams off his HBCU loyalty alone

 

[Lakers Offseason]

Hands down

 

[RubioTheCruel]

Easily Moon.

McNabb's up there, wasn't given a lot to work with most of his career; when he did get a legit #1 WR he got to the SB.

McNair/Cunningham were nice too

 

[godkiller]

It will be Jameis Winston, Jeremy Johnson and the Clemson QB too if the gods are good.

 

[patscorpio]

David Garrard

i actually liked that dude...man the jags did him dirty

 

[Danie84]

Personally, Prime Vick is my GOAT Black QB

...those dayum CaCsucking Dawgz

Respect to Doug William for being the First to win a Super Bowl: BLACKEXCELLENCE

 

[Dominique Wilkins]

Warren Moon

but I also liked Randall Cunningham