Who would you say is the best storyteller in gaming?

SupaHotIce

All Star
Joined
Jan 8, 2015
Messages
3,407
Reputation
530
Daps
8,937
kojima-boss-strut.0.gif
 

Ezekiel 25:17

Veteran
Joined
Jul 17, 2018
Messages
35,480
Reputation
2,483
Daps
126,948
No one in the stratosphere as Naughty Dog. And save me the kiddie anime, rescue the princess, evil lose, good win safe ass Disney shyt


You smoking crack. The Witcher series dog walks Naughty Dog. Now maybe that's not fair because they had the books prior, but point still stands. The Last of Us pales in comparison to the Witcher and Cyberpunk 2077.


800px-MikePondsmith.jpg
 

Ezekiel 25:17

Veteran
Joined
Jul 17, 2018
Messages
35,480
Reputation
2,483
Daps
126,948
Neil on another level. nikkaz gon get mad, but it's true.



Naughty dog is similar to GTA. Good surface level story telling, but nothing deep and no lore. The GOAT story tellers need lore, otherwise it's a one and done thing.

The Witcher you can talk about all day long.

Santa Monica. You can talk about God of War all day long.

Hideo Kojima is another. You can talk about Metal Gear solid all day long.
 

Diondon

Thanks to the lawyers uh, I marbled the foyer
Joined
Mar 19, 2013
Messages
40,417
Reputation
9,219
Daps
179,962
Reppin
Somewhere tropic...
You smoking crack. The Witcher series dog walks Naughty Dog. Now maybe that's not fair because they had the books prior, but point still stands. The Last of Us pales in comparison to the Witcher and Cyberpunk 2077.


800px-MikePondsmith.jpg
Decent stories, pretty much standard tropes, no emotional gutpunch
I've seen grown men & women bawl like babies to this day especially to TLOU 1 & 2
A story where seeking revenge to the point of obsession leading to pain & destruction with no happy ending
Bruh, who in gaming is doing this?
 

Ezekiel 25:17

Veteran
Joined
Jul 17, 2018
Messages
35,480
Reputation
2,483
Daps
126,948
Decent stories, pretty much standard tropes, no emotional gutpunch
I've seen grown men & women bawl like babies to this day especially to TLOU 1 & 2
A story where seeking revenge to the point of obsession leading to pain & destruction with no happy ending
Bruh, who in gaming is doing this?

Not trying to judge, but those are what you call 'casuals'. The Last of Us is surface level story telling, ANYBODY can do what Neil did. But how many people can do what CDPR or Hideo Kojima did?:ufdup:

The Last of Us has no real back story, there's no lore. Is it good? Sure, but it's amateur hour compared to the likes of Witcher, Cyberpunk, and God of War.
 

Diunx

Probably drunk
Joined
Nov 18, 2013
Messages
14,910
Reputation
2,063
Daps
44,539
Reppin
nightset
No one in the stratosphere as Naughty Dog. And save me the kiddie anime, rescue the princess, evil lose, good win safe ass Disney shyt
Lol gtfo, TLOU 2 was full of generic evil for the sake of evil BS, I love the games but this idea that the narrative is on another level just because they spent a ton of money on cutscenes is nonsense.

The story and script on those games is nothing special
 

Jaguar93

Veteran
Joined
Jan 28, 2016
Messages
16,787
Reputation
4,645
Daps
81,597
:russ: I like TLOU2’s story even with the horrible pacing. I especially like how Neil didn’t play it safe with certain characters. But I wouldn’t say that the narrative “is on another level” lol.
 

Diondon

Thanks to the lawyers uh, I marbled the foyer
Joined
Mar 19, 2013
Messages
40,417
Reputation
9,219
Daps
179,962
Reppin
Somewhere tropic...
Not trying to judge, but those are what you call 'casuals'. The Last of Us is surface level story telling, ANYBODY can do what Neil did. But how many people can do what CDPR or Hideo Kojima did?:ufdup:
But they don't


The Last of Us has no real back story, there's no lore. Is it good? Sure, but it's amateur hour compared to the likes of Witcher, Cyberpunk, and God of War.
A modern day story that doesn't have lore or mythology to use as crux is harder to pull off
Even Uncharted capitalized off lore.
 

Diondon

Thanks to the lawyers uh, I marbled the foyer
Joined
Mar 19, 2013
Messages
40,417
Reputation
9,219
Daps
179,962
Reppin
Somewhere tropic...
Lol gtfo, TLOU 2 was full of generic evil for the sake of evil BS, I love the games but this idea that the narrative is on another level just because they spent a ton of money on cutscenes is nonsense.

The story and script on those games is nothing special
Who in TLOU is evil? :jbhmm:
 

Ezekiel 25:17

Veteran
Joined
Jul 17, 2018
Messages
35,480
Reputation
2,483
Daps
126,948
But they don't



A modern day story that doesn't have lore or mythology to use as crux is harder to pull off
Even Uncharted capitalized off lore.

You're not really giving any solid arguments. Neil's writing can absolutely be reciprocated, that's the entire point. The last of us is good, but it's one and done. Again, name someone who can do a game like the Metal Gear Solid or Witcher or the God of War series. Those games are backed by solid authors who wrote 3 and 4 books. God of War is it's own entity.

Witcher 3 and Metal Gear Solid stomps out anything Naughty Dog has made story wise. It's not even fair to compare. And Witcher 4 is catching even more bodies
 

Diunx

Probably drunk
Joined
Nov 18, 2013
Messages
14,910
Reputation
2,063
Daps
44,539
Reppin
nightset
Who in TLOU is evil? :jbhmm:
The religious freak torturing kids and breaking their arms, the dude that wants to straight up shoot a kid, the pedo cannibal, the guys that kept obsessively chasing us with a tank just because.
 

Diondon

Thanks to the lawyers uh, I marbled the foyer
Joined
Mar 19, 2013
Messages
40,417
Reputation
9,219
Daps
179,962
Reppin
Somewhere tropic...
You're not really giving any solid arguments. Neil's writing can absolutely be reciprocated, that's the entire point. The last of us is good, but it's one and done. Again, name someone who can do a game like the Metal Gear Solid or Witcher or the God of War series. Those games are backed by solid authors who wrote 3 and 4 books. God of War is it's own entity.

Witcher 3 and Metal Gear Solid stomps out anything Naughty Dog has made story wise. It's not even fair to compare. And Witcher 4 is catching even more bodies
Ehh we're going in circles
and will have to agree to disagree
None of those games incite the level of discussion or reaction of TLOU. A simple Youtube search will suffice.
Again, its not your typical videogame story; good defeats evil. Everyone feels good.
 

Diunx

Probably drunk
Joined
Nov 18, 2013
Messages
14,910
Reputation
2,063
Daps
44,539
Reppin
nightset
Ehh we're going in circles
and will have to agree to disagree
None of those games incite the level of discussion or reaction of TLOU. A simple Youtube search will suffice.
Again, its not your typical videogame story; good defeats evil. Everyone feels good.
Lol people still talk about MGS 2 story, specially with all the AI nonsense these last few years.
 
Top