who's better brady or Peyton

calh45

Cal
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
12,227
Reputation
2,280
Daps
42,731
Why does it always have to be extremes in the case of Brady/Manning ?

in this country you have to pick sides. I don't know when it happened, but that's the way it is now. If you like Bron you can't also like Kobe or Tim. If you like Peyton you can't like Brady. It's crazy they can't both be appreciated. They both do things different, but they're both legit top 5 all time. Peyton develops his offense better. Brady is more of a warrior/fighter.
 

Based Lord Zedd

Colts or Die
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
11,606
Reputation
1,629
Daps
32,572
Reppin
Houston TX
Nobody didnt mention seytons game losing pick against the saints.....


Find me a super bowl where Brady did that


What you can find is Brady giving his teams the lead with 3 or so minutes left.
What you can find is an 18-8 playoff record (best playoff record for QB in NFL History) Compared to manning's 11-12
What you can find is Brady beating that broncos team last year after being down 24-0
What you can find a 9-5 Record against any Manning lead team
You can also find a 3-5 Super bowl record vs Manning's 1-3

In history no one will care if Manning beat the shyt out of teams like the raiders and texans and got big stat lines they wanna see the big game performances.
I think there both great and i talk alot of shyt about seyton but if you look at the facts who is better than whom?

In history I hope people aren't completing ignoring individual performance and only comparing the two based on TEAM head-to-head record and TEAM wins.

Football fans supposed to get smarter as time goes on.
 
Joined
Oct 13, 2014
Messages
565
Reputation
90
Daps
669
Reppin
Def Jam Empire
In history I hope people aren't completing ignoring individual performance and only comparing the two based on TEAM head-to-head record and TEAM wins.

Football fans supposed to get smarter as time goes on.


Well it's a TEAM SPORT so i imagine that's where most of the focus will go. And since it's a thread comparing the two and saying one wassnt even on the same LEVEL as the other I figured that would be the best way to do it a (Head to Head comparison)
 

Rigby.

The #1 Rated Mixtape of all Time
Joined
Jun 20, 2014
Messages
52,039
Reputation
2,445
Daps
74,697
Reppin
JordanHareStadium
you're about as bright as a nightlight, aren't you...
Call people dumb when they say something you don't agree with, the fact is Brady got blessed to be in a good spot with usually great talent. once that talent decreased, Brady stopped even being a top 5 QB, and this season he may be closer in the 11-15th range
 

Carlos Huerta

Just keep my rep red
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
7,004
Reputation
-292
Daps
8,733
Reppin
NULL
Call people dumb when they say something you don't agree with, the fact is Brady got blessed to be in a good spot with usually great talent. once that talent decreased, Brady stopped even being a top 5 QB, and this season he may be closer in the 11-15th range
another dumb post. You stay killin it.
 
Top