Who's discography is better, 2 Pac or Kanye West?

Better Discography?


  • Total voters
    138
  • Poll closed .

The Ruler 09

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Jul 14, 2012
Messages
39,087
Reputation
1,866
Daps
38,374
Reppin
NULL
I get the feeling you aren't really reading my posts. At least the earlier ones. I've explicitly said I think Tupac is the better rapper. I also said however, that if we're simply looking at albums, and their musical quality (which from what I understand, is what you look at when you analyze a discography), then Kanye wins.

I've said it before in this thread and I'll say it again: just because a rapper has a better discography than another, does not mean he is automatically the better rapper.

I've read all your posts bro. I still disagree, I'm talking strictly ALBUMS not MC skill or anything. I think 2 Pac has some of the greatest Hip Hop songs and albums, Kanye started off well and was refreshing in that climate but fell off to me. When you analyse the quality of work within Pac's albums it surpasses Kanye's.
 

Nomad1

Tupac KONY and GOAT
Joined
Jun 23, 2013
Messages
13,896
Reputation
4,070
Daps
40,213
Reppin
Toronto
no1 called pac the greatest ever when he was alive :mjpls:
nikka I was fukking alive when 2pac was in his prime. I was living in LA and nikkas loved Pac. None was calling anyone the "GOAT" in the 90's. That argument is revisionist history that is only used against Pac. There are dozens of rappers from the 90's who weren't called GOATs and some of them are completely underrated until this day ex Scarface.
 

Prince Cairo

Authentic
Joined
Dec 12, 2013
Messages
3,353
Reputation
1,140
Daps
9,651
Reppin
Cairo, Egypt
I've read all your posts bro. I still disagree, I'm talking strictly ALBUMS not MC skill or anything. I think 2 Pac has some of the greatest Hip Hop songs and albums, Kanye started off well and was refreshing in that climate but fell off to me. When you analyse the quality of work within Pac's albums it surpasses Kanye's.

I guess this is the point where subjectivity just wins. I just wanted to make sure you understood my actual position here. A lot of Pac stans seriously believe that even the mention of another rapper doing something great is blasphemy, and I can't respect that. I have no squabbles disagreeing with you over whose music is of a higher quality though.. that's what taste is all about. Peace.
 

CouldntBeMeTho

The Big Tuna
Supporter
Joined
Jul 14, 2012
Messages
49,359
Reputation
23,156
Daps
278,900
Reppin
Dog Shooting Squad Of Islamabad
tumblr_inline_nbyw9tg2BG1rz44at.gif


I think I've had enough. Pac stans are the worst. Fabricating someone’s catalog in order to guarantee them fantasy wins in debate is not paying homage. Paying homage is saying exactly what their quality was and believing in it enough to feel that their opposition would take a loss, or have a very hard time winning. That’s how you pay respect to your icons. Paying true homage to an artist is to actually accept their skills for what they were, instead of fabricating them to superhuman levels to support our arguments. Peace

tumblr_mrw1ndjYdx1s7m6b9o1_500.gif
 

The Ruler 09

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Jul 14, 2012
Messages
39,087
Reputation
1,866
Daps
38,374
Reppin
NULL
I guess this is the point where subjectivity just wins. I just wanted to make sure you understood my actual position here. A lot of Pac stans seriously believe that even the mention of another rapper doing something great is blasphemy, and I can't respect that. I have no squabbles disagreeing with you over whose music is of a higher quality though.. that's what taste is all about. Peace.

Yeah likewise, you've always been reasonable and civil when we've debated so it's just opinions and shyt, it's all good. Yeah I understood what you were saying, it's just a disagreement within the content, but I certainly understood the points. Course many other rappers did great things, even Kanye, I fukk with TCD, and even LR for the most part and even Graduation was good, but I would disagree the work after was stellar. Yeah exactly, agree with that. Peace man.
 

Nomad1

Tupac KONY and GOAT
Joined
Jun 23, 2013
Messages
13,896
Reputation
4,070
Daps
40,213
Reppin
Toronto
yo im done. :dead:

Pac has way better songs than Kanye has ever written. nikkas only claim Kanye has better albums is becuase it's pop as fukk:camby:

I change my original comment :pacspit:Kanye and :pacspit:his wack ass albums. Bunch of wack ass shyt.

And Illmatic>Ye's existence :umad:
 
Top