Who's The True GOAT: Pete Carroll or Nick Saban?

[EducatedBrothaFromTheBank]

Saying that, his career before Russell Wilson in the NFL was also

won a playoff game without Wilson..

 

[NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong]

Can't you use the same logic and just say Pete inherited the Pats team put together by Parcells?

to some degree. pete had a better winning % there than parcells though. he changed the roster a bit...lost curtis martin to parcells and the jets and had to deal with losing robert edwards to a torn acl. he had terry allen and kevin faulk as his lead backs when he went 8-8 his last year. his defense ranked higher than parcells' with those players too. http://www.pro-football-reference.com/teams/nwe/

 

[South Paw]

Pete didn't have final say on personnel decisions on his previous NFL jobs like he does now

 

[mastermind]

won a playoff game without Wilson..

cool

Norv Turner has won 4 playoff games.

 

[NaijaProdigy Redux]

Mike Dikta overrated bruh

I must have stared at that photo 20 times asking myself "nah that ain't Mike Dikta is it? That looks like Jimmy Johnson Am I going fukking blind?"

 

[Carlos Huerta]

Urban Meyer:
2 National Championships
2 SEC championships
Big 10 Championship
Undefeated seasons at both Ohio State and Utah ( still has yet to lose a B1G conference game in three years)

What was the point of posting this? It doesn't compare to Pete's or Nick's resumes. Let's also forget about the fact that this dude ran when he lost his QB and the competition got better in his conference.

 

[malbaker86]

What was the point of posting this? It doesn't compare to Pete's or Nick's resumes. Let's also forget about the fact that this dude ran when he lost his QB and the competition got better in his conference.

So you're saying that you don't think had he stayed at UF they wouldn't be a top 5-10 school? Don't be ridiculous. As far as losing his QB, he would have inherited another spread QB in Driskel had he stayed beyond 2010. Talent and comp wasn't the reason he left, he lost control of the program.

 

[Carlos Huerta]

So you're saying that you don't think had he stayed at UF they wouldn't be a top 5-10 school? Don't be ridiculous. As far as losing his QB, he would have inherited another spread QB in Driskel had he stayed beyond 2010. Talent and comp wasn't the reason he left, he lost control of the program.

He wouldn't have won another SEC championship

 

[malbaker86]

He wouldn't have won another SEC championship

 

[Sterling Archer]

Brehs in here talking about my Alma Mater and my coach and not even @ me? :belipup:

 

[CrimsonTider]

Saban

He has to compete against the SEC

 

[Ruck]

He's up there in terms of coaching legacy in all sports with Belichick (he is a Belichick guy) and Gregg Popovich, in my opinion.

no just no. don't ever compare saban to someone like pop... EVER!

 

[Silkk]

So you're saying that you don't think had he stayed at UF they wouldn't be a top 5-10 school? Don't be ridiculous. As far as losing his QB, he would have inherited another spread QB in Driskel had he stayed beyond 2010. Talent and comp wasn't the reason he left, he lost control of the program.

He saw the writing on the wall and bolted, then he saw how easy his path would be at Ohio St and "his health recovered"

 

[HacksawJimThuggin]

Is this thread solely about college coaches that have coached in the NFL? If so, then I got Jimmy Johnson as the GOAT. Probably Pete, then Saban. Saban is gonna go down as the best college football coach ever though.

Spoiler

Bowden would have that GOAT title for life if only we had more reliable kickers