Who's trophy case is more impressive?

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

If based solely on exclusivity then yes. But there are Hesiman winners who couldn't even make it in the league.

true, but their list beings and ends with

"Heisman trophy winner"

 

[meth68]

getting a heisman trophy is a more elite group than getting a superbowl. BETTER PLAYERS have superbowls but the heisman club IS MORE ELITE than the 'superbowl winners' club. I'm not trying to convince in either direction but the heisman club is more special than the superbowl club because of exclusivity.

You are out of your mind
Last 20 years, go tell them if they would trade in their Heismans for SB trophies for their case.. Bradford? Leinart? Crouch? Dayne? White? Tebow? Smith? Palmar? Wurffel? Weinke? Yes elite company for sure...

 

[Raquinotj]

getting a heisman trophy is a more elite group than getting a superbowl. BETTER PLAYERS have superbowls but the heisman club IS MORE ELITE than the 'superbowl winners' club. I'm not trying to convince in either direction but the heisman club is more special than the superbowl club because of exclusivity.

• 4 Rings> 1 Ring
• 3 Super Bowl MVPs> 1 DPOY
• 10X Pro Bowl as a QB >>> 8 Time Pro Bowl as a DB
• 6x AFC Champ >>> 1x NFC 1XAFC Champ
• 2 NFL MVPs >>> Heisman Trophy Agree?

 

[Tommy Sheppard]

both are 2 of the goats at there positions at the end of the day, who cares about what trophies they have?

 

[Pesci]

it's actually a good discussion

you could make the argument that Charles Woodson is the best defensive back of all-time

 

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

• 4 Rings> 1 Ring
• 3 Super Bowl MVPs> 1 DPOY
• 10X Pro Bowl as a QB >>> 8 Time Pro Bowl as a DB
• 6x AFC Champ >>> 1x NFC 1XAFC Champ
• 2 NFL MVPs >>> Heisman Trophy Agree?

yeah with the exception of the bolded I agree, so vote brady then why are you so mad.

there are more individual achievements by woodson, more TEAM achievements by brady

 

[Raquinotj]

it's actually a good discussion

you could make the argument that Charles Woodson is the best defensive back of all-time

Over Deion Sanders, Rod Woodson, Ronnie Lott and Darelle Green?

 

[Raquinotj]

yeah with the exception of the bolded I agree, so vote brady then why are you so mad.

there are more individual achievements by woodson, more TEAM achievements by brady

I'm not mad, I'm stating my point.

 

[meth68]

it's actually a good discussion

you could make the argument that Charles Woodson is the best defensive back of all-time

I am not hating on Woodson, he was awesome, but Best DB of all time? Tell that to Lott.. Hes not even the best DB named Woodson let alone all time.

Football nation dont even have him in the top 10 of all time, we all realize NFL started pre-1995 right?
1. Lott
2. Deion
3. Champ
4. Green
5. Rod Woodson
6. Jake Scott
7. Ed Reed
8. Mel Blount
9. Ty Law
10. dikk LeBeau

 

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

I am not hating on Woodson, he was awesome, but Best DB of all time? Tell that to Lott.. Hes not even the best DB named Woodson let alone all time.

Football nation dont even have him in the top 10 of all time, we all realize NFL started pre-1995 right?
1. Lott
2. Deion
3. Champ
4. Green
5. Rod Woodson
6. Jake Scott
7. Ed Reed
8. Mel Blount
9. Ty Law
10. dikk LeBeau

he is unquestionably better than anyone below #2. you're OUT OF YOUR MIND if you think CHAMP BAILEY IS IN HIS LEAGUE.

 

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

CHAMP BAILEY

REALLY

CHAMP BAILEY damn breh i had to hit bACK on that one

 

[meth68]

CHAMP BAILEY

REALLY

CHAMP BAILEY damn breh i had to hit bACK on that one

Bro your a mich stan of course you will disagree, go send your hatemail to http://www.footballnation.com/content/nfls-all-time-top-10-defensive-backs/21872/

Do you think hes better then Lott? Deion? Rod Woodson?Blunt? LeBeau? Green? Goooo ahead I will wait

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

PLEASE make the champ bailey vs charles Woodson thread with a poll o DARE YOU

 

[Ohene]

champ bailey aint seeing my dude charles

 

[meth68]

champ bailey aint seeing my dude charles

Are we going to ignore the others as well? Lott? Deion? Rod Woodson?Blunt? LeBeau? Green?

@Ed MOTHERfukkING G you trollin hard for your Michigan , dont be that guy.... Whats next OSU stans saying eddie george is goat?