Who's your top 5 QB's All Time
- Thread starter producingfire
- Start date
28 Gramz
How U Luv That???
Some of y'all don't have Brady in your top 5?
Not having him #1 is actually insane.
staticshock
Veteran
Peyton
Brady
Vick
Marino
Rodgers
Not say those are the best 5..just my favorite 5
Brady
Vick
Marino
Rodgers
Not say those are the best 5..just my favorite 5
This is what happens when you recently retire and you crushed a lot of people's hopes and dreams. The thing with Brady to, is he looked absurdly normal, and yet clinical it's difficult to put into words. No one can deny he made teams better. One would think Rogers would have that level of success but nope. I mean if Rogers had the same accolades I think people would understand, but Brady... I think Rogers has more talent in the since of he can do more things, but Tom got every ounce of talent out of himself and elevated the team around him. Made receivers house hold names etc..Some of y'all don't have Brady in your top 5?
YakSpiller
Veteran
Peyton Manning the GOAT
All the others are interchangeable for me.
All the others are interchangeable for me.
BlueHeffner
Veteran
1. Brady
2. Peyton
3. Joe Montana
4. Mahomes
5. Marino
2. Peyton
3. Joe Montana
4. Mahomes
5. Marino
BigE214
Future GOAT
I always felt Peyton was a better QB. Couple that with, spy, deflate and unknown gate, I'm cool with Tom being borderline top 5
Yeah agreed. We have the same name's on our top 5' just a different order, so I definitely can resonate with this one.
Some of y'all don't have Brady in your top 5?
yeah that’s crazy…also too early to be mentioning mahomes imo in a best of all time discussion
BigE214
Future GOAT
also Tom has 3 first team all pro selections his career. Mahomes has 2 already 
2 superbowls with 2 superbowl mvps, 2 league with 3 appearances. There are QB's that play there whole career and never get anywhere near that. If Mahomes retired today he's a first ballet Hall of Famer.
Montana
P Manning
Mr Sunday Night
E Manning
Bree$
P Manning
Mr Sunday Night
E Manning
Bree$
that still doesn’t make him suitable for a best of all time discussion right now
AlbertPullhoez
The Takeover
Brady
Montana
Mahomes
Peyton
Staubach
Montana
Mahomes
Peyton
Staubach
cool we can agree to disagree on that