Whose NBA career was better? Carmelo Anthony vs. Vince Carter

[75 Others]

The Melo slander

 

[AlbertPullhoez]

Vince Carter is 1000 times better than Melo. Carter is a winner and unselfish team player. It’s disgusting Melo is only known as team cancer.
Ohh this is for Melo biggest fan I won’t tag you because you know who you are. fukk Melo.

The fukk has Vince Carter ever won?

Melo has been farther in the postseason than Vince has

 

[606onit]

Carter because he seems like a better person and he has some classic moments.

 

[Chris Cool]

Melo led a team to the wcf.

 

[#1 pick]

VC for me. Even with age he keeps adding to his game. Melo was an elite one trick pony in his prime tho

 

[letti cook]

Melo had a better career but Vince will have the better legacy off the strength of his Raptor years


Melo is like Fabolous or Jadakiss...Vince is Snoop

 

[TaxCollector13459]

Melo is a legend. Vince Carter is pretty much known as a dunker only

He helped an entire country get excited about hoops and their first legit star

 

[Youngdev]

Vince we be looked at better cause of the dunking ,melo pretty much universally hated other than Bmore and Syracuse. Vince done stuck around and been the great role model. While melo blackballed himself out the league.


Melo>>>>Vince tho to me

 

[BXKingPin82]

Carmelo

Cause his hat game shyts all over Cole's from Martin.

 

[intruder]

Melo got more accolades numbers wise, but Vince gonna mean more to fans and the NBA in the end.

Exactly!

Melo may have the accolades but you CANNOT tell the story of 2000s basketball without mentioning Vince Carter. You CAN tell it without mentioning Melo, tho.
I guess Vince is more iconic than Melo in a way.

 

[intruder]

Melo lead a team to the wcf.

Didnt Vince go to the ECF with Kidd and the Nets? I thought he did in that series where Wade stole the ball from him before he could take the last-second shot. I could be wrong

 

[filial_piety]

At their peak, I'd say VC was better. And he was without a doubt a better athlete. But as for their careers, 'd have to say Melo and I say this as someone who NEVER liked Melo's game.

 

[Damnshow]

I wonder did melo do something behind the scenes to some group of people or something? The way his reputation has been getting destroyed is worrysome.

 

[Damnshow]

Didnt Vince go to the ECF with Kidd and the Nets? I thought he did in that series where Wade stole the ball from him before he could take the last-second shot. I could be wrong

vince only made it to ECF once when he was a role player in orlando, the series where celtics took care of them pretty easily

 

[Po pimp]

Vince was more of a star at his peak, but Melo had the better career. Melo actually got his team to a conference finals as the best player on his team. Not to mention he’s accumulated more individual accolades.