Why Do Nas and Jay Get a Pass, But Eminem Doesn't ...

[the cac mamba]

nas or hov have NEVER dropped an encore

 

[ML29]

Is it possible to just not like Eminem, because maybe, just maybe you may not like his music. The whole "they only hate him cuz he's white excuse" is beyond played out.

 

[kidofthekids]

EM makes shytty pop rap..no real shyt any real nikka should bump in the hood

"real nikka" lol....

 

[mikishere]

nas or hov have NEVER dropped an encore

 

[the cac mamba]

idk breh that doesnt have a 'fack' on it

 

[MINT]

hmm

 

[JYoung24]

People on here & Boxden keep saying that Eminem doesn't deserve to be mentioned amongst the Goats because of his "sh*tty catalogue".

Em isn't one of my favorite rappers anymore but why does Nas (or Jay-Z) get a pass for all his sh*tty albums, but Em doesn't ?

Do you think Em is disrespected because of his skin color ?

Half of jay's disco is trash lol

Nas doent have a shytty catalouge

 

[The_Third_Man]

Since when Jay and Nas get passes for anything?

By the way, Eminem catalogue isn't half as good as jay's and nas's

 

[prophecypro]

For one they got better catalogues than Em.

But its whatever, because truth be told Eminem does ranked in people's top 5-10

 

[inndaskKy]

idk breh that doesnt have a 'fack' on it

Neither does Encore.

 

[avon barksdale]

because songs like this...

 

[SunZoo]

idk breh that doesnt have a 'fack' on it

Neither does encore.

Truth be told Nastradamus doesn't have an evil deeds or a mosh.

 

[Ziggiy]

Nas has amongst the strongest album catalogues in Hip Hop history, Jay also has a very impressive catogue. To compare these two catalogues to Cacinem is a disgrace to the genre. Matter of fact the OP deserves a neg rep which I am more than happy to oblige

 

[Budda]

You should be asking why Em can put out pop songs like this and still be considered an elite rapper, Nas got more hate for putting out better songs on better albums.

 

[intilectual recipricol]

One thing I can say about Eminem, he is easily a better writer than naS. Even if he purposely uses it to be corny sometimes. He is very deliberate in his word placement which is a large part of being a great writer. naS haphazardly throws nonsensical shyt together and thinks that it is dope.

So I'm at an impasse, is it worse to be extremely deliberate and purposely corny or worse to be unknowingly corny but think that its dope?

I dont know, I view their catalogs as about even although naS has the best album between them with IWW, but he also has the worst album between them with illmatic. naS is the better storyteller, but Em is a more polished writer.

This is a toughie