I wouldn't consider him a biter. He was still trying to find his sound and all rappers learn from and are influenced by the rap that came before them.
And I said it was mainstream friendly. Meaning the style/content and everything would've been perfectly acceptable by a mainstream audience, especially since it pretty much followed the style of Illmatic/Doe or Die and rap had a number of successful lyrical rappers at the time.
Whether he's a gimmick or not is a matter of opinion. You could argue that he is/was.
And you do have a point that there was successful rap music that revolved around violence and non family-friendly content that was highly successful. But I was speaking more in general. If you have a new artist who has 2 types of songs, which do you think labels would prefer to put out and expect more people to gravitate towards?:
1) a club type record and just catchy type of music that will hit a wide audience
2) record about dumping your baby's mom into a lake, slicing off a woman's nipple and raping her, etc
As far as advancing/evolving - I was just referring to his music going from Infinite to SSLP. Obviously Encore was worse than TES.
I still don't see how Encore was selling out. He didn't change his style or content in any significant way (especially if you compare it to his immature music around SSLP), he just put out shyt quality. I think you're letting the horrible quality blind you from the fact that at it's core, Encore is the same goofball music that Em has been doing since he first became popular.
As I already said I don't think you're very familiar Eminem and his career if you think Encore is some crazy left field out of the ordinary record for him. Encore was basically like Hi My Name Is, Real Slim Shady, Without Me, Purple Pills type songs for an entire album.
It wasn't a mainstream album. Nor was it mainstream friendly in the sense of being very commercial. Illmatic and Do Or Die weren't either.
Those weren't the two options, that wasn't the only song/theme on the album. It was a crazy WHITE guy with an attitude that had some rappin ability that was backed by Dre. It was basically a updated Vanilla Ice marketing scheme. (not artistically).
Lol heard every album in his career and most songs so I'm pretty familiar with his career.
Anyway, ultimately this is about Lord Jamar lol.