I skimmed through this thread. I’m surprised not many touched on the actual music.
I honestly believe some of this post stems from NY projects that you seem to hold in high regard, yet the rest of the Coli doesn’t feel the same.
I’ll give you an example. You loved the Kay Slay album that came out last year. However, you had plenty of people such as myself that thought it was awful due to the poor beat selection. Is that really hating? The consensus was it was trash, yet you seemed to gravitate towards it.
In all honesty, the newer artist you listed just sound like knockoff southern/ Midwest artists. The reality is no one can do those regions like them just as no one can do NY like NY.
Finally, I do feel the perspective of certain NY artist is just different if you aren’t from NY. NY will tell you Jadakiss is top 5, yet I don’t think the guy can could put together a good album. Therefore, to me it’s just mind boggling that many feel that way about a guy more suited for a group. Many people feel that way. Fab is also very similar in that regard, but he’s been able to put together some strong mixtapes. Cam consistently puts together bad projects cheap production and poor engineering, and then come of with some of the corniest samples. Dime after Dime? Really? What kind of opinion do you expect ? The COC/Roc days are long gone.
A lot of those Ny artist (jada,fab, cam) don’t put out good albums. Their best work is with mixtapes, and you have to be a hardcore fan to really check for those.
However, if you are from NY, perhaps you don’t feel that way at all. Maybe you believe Jadakiss actually puts out good albums.
It’s all subjective.