Tomlin ain't looked at as an elite coach because of all the extra bullshyt.
Team constantly would go for two point conversions after scoring the opening TD
Players showboat ALL THE TIME
Seems to not have control of his locker-room
Team constantly plays down to their oppenents
Too much of a "Player coach"
Last but not least...they call him undisciplined because of everything I listed above.
With this said, damn near everything that is said is somewhat true but even through it all dude continues to win. I personally wouldn't give him up for anyone else and I'm sure outside of NE and Seattle every other team would trade their coach for him.