With 2 rings, is Eli Manning a HOF'er?

[phillycavsfan]

It gets posted too much arguably but it's so necessary here.

 

[Liquid]

He will reach that 45-50K passing yards mark barring any injury + the 2 rings in NY + 2x Superbowl MVP

All time NYG leader in touchdowns and yards
3x pro bowler

He'll get in.

 

[mrken12]

 

[Ku$h Parker]

He'll get in before RGIII tho

 

[RiffRaff]

Ben's been in 3 superbowls. Won 2 of them and has put up better career stats than Eli. If he keeps playing similar to how he has over duration of his career he's a lock.

Eli IMO has a lot of work to do still. He needs to play like a top 10 QB for at least 2 more seasons in his career to make it or have another deep playoff run

 

[Self_Born7]

 

[True Weltch Media]

Ben is way more consistent and should be a lock when he decides to retire. Eli has to cut down on them picks in order to get in the hall. He has a good chance tho

 

[Rick Roller 10]

Might as well out David tyree in the HOF then..

 

[duncanthetall]

Eli is below average as a QB now. His chance to add on his legacy seems to be gone, at least at the moment.

 

[Reggie]

Like it or not when Manning retires he will be in the Hall of Fame. He'll probably have over 300 touchdowns and 50,000 yards along with those two rings which will put him over the top. And playing in New York doesn't hurt either cause they are going to hype the hell out of him when that time comes.

 

[nomoreneveragain]

Troy Aikman < Eli Manning

 

[Silkk]

Eli, Ben, and Philip will all get in the hall imo

Phillip who?

 

[ExodusNirvana]

He will get in quite easily despite whatever stupidity is said in this thread

 

[STAN JONES]

Eli fell off too early

If he can somehow put together 4 or 5 more good years he'll get in

Big Ben will make it IMO

 

[nomoreneveragain]

This time next year this won't even be a discussion.

With Beckham (And Cruz Coming Back) & another year under McAdoo, he's going to be putting ridiculous #'s

He's had a really good year this year too.