Worst draft pick since 2010 NFL draft QB's only
- Thread starter Tide Run This
- Start date
@jaguar paw Tell these nikkas about the Weeden flip
Manziel and Weeden should've just been one option.
Tide Run This
Veteran
Ponder overachieved in college Manuel underachieved switch teams I think Ponder wins a title with 2012 FSU team Ponder never played with anything close to the talent EJ had around him. Both had no business being 1st round anything.
MooseMouthMthafuga
Veteran
I knew a dude named "Gabbert" wasn't destined for greatness when I first heard it.
Shyt had bust written all over it.
Just like when the 49ers drafted "Jim Druckenmiller".....I knew that shyt wasn't going to work out
What shocked me even more is they took him over Jake Plummer who was basically a Joe Montana clone at the time.
Even Bill Walsh was going around raving about Jake & saying how he reminded him of Joe Cool.
Y'all might laugh now, but Jake was probably one of the most promising young QB's in the NFL his first 3 seasons.
He got the Cardinals to the playoffs in only his 2nd year.That's the equivalent of a 2nd year QB getting the Jaguars
to the offs right now.
If Manuel played another year we would've had that '13 national championship
I voted Locker, but there's plenty of guys on the list who could be the worst. Locker got hyped for a couple years, especially by that hack McShay, like he was the next legend at the QB position. Not even in the league after four seasons. 
At least scrubs like Ponder and Gabbert completed 60% of their passes in one of their college seasons. Locker's senior season he completed 55.4% of his throws.
At least scrubs like Ponder and Gabbert completed 60% of their passes in one of their college seasons. Locker's senior season he completed 55.4% of his throws.
Mantis Toboggan M.D.
I’m here for the scraps
Gabbert was so bad that after 2-3 years his team gave up on him for Bortles, who has put up I think 60-65% of his numbers when the game is out of reach. Clausen on the other hand? He made us think Steve Smith was washed up he was so bad
Last edited:
Man if Ponder didn't have AD running that ball
That saved him and got him a playoff berth
That saved him and got him a playoff berth
MooseMouthMthafuga
Veteran
I voted Locker, but there's plenty of guys on the list who could be the worst. Locker got hyped for a couple years, especially by that hack McShay, like he was the next legend at the QB position. Not even in the league after four seasons.
At least scrubs like Ponder and Gabbert completed 60% of their passes in one of their college seasons. Locker's senior season he completed 55.4% of his throws.
I remember some scout saying Locker was the GOAT QB prospect.I mean, just raving about his measurables.
Shyt had me
........I never got the hypeThat's why Locker got my vote. None of these other guys got hyped like they were Montana, Cunningham and Favre rolled in one. :loldenzel:I remember some scout saying Locker was the GOAT QB prospect.I mean, just raving about his measurables.
Shyt had me
R.E.N. Spells Ren
Veteran
Tebow.
How can you call yourself a professional evaluator of talent and think Tim Tebow was a first round talent
How can you call yourself a professional evaluator of talent and think Tim Tebow was a first round talent
I voted Ponder and Manuel. Even though guys like Gabbert and Manziel were wrongly hyped, they were still hyped. No one was even thinking of Ponder and Manuel for the first round. Remember Bill Simmons reaction when Anthony Bennett got drafted? That was me when Christian Ponder's name got announced 
I still have hope for Bottles....he can make all the throws, not sure what happened to him.
Manziel....because you could have had Carr, Bridgewater (RIP his knee) or Garrapallo instead. I feel it's worse when there was not just other players, but other players at the same position.
Manziel....because you could have had Carr, Bridgewater (RIP his knee) or Garrapallo instead. I feel it's worse when there was not just other players, but other players at the same position.