Would Peyton have lost 2 Superbowls 2 his lil brother Eli?

[Amare's Right Hook]

Yes

 

[No1]

he didnt play like a bum and saints had the best passing d in the leauge

 

[THE MACHINE]

If he has the squad that he won the first SB with then Peyton wins. If they are as dependent on him as they were the second go round then that Giants front four would have been real good and the Giants win.

That Pats team that lost the first SB to the Giants was arguably the greatest team ever assembled....until Superbowl Sunday that is.

Some of y'all pay to much attention to Jaws, he has yall thinking Peyton is better than Brady.

 

[FTBS]

That Pats team that lost the first SB to the Giants was arguably the greatest team ever assembled....until Superbowl Sunday that is.

Some of y'all pay to much attention to Jaws, he has yall thinking Peyton is better than Brady.

What does any of that have to do with what I said? My analysis wasn't even about Peyton is was all about the team around him. You probably didnt' even read my post. You probably just saw the words "Peyton" and "wins" next to each other and instantly got and instead of actually trying to understand what I was saying. Not the first or the last.

 

[JYoung24]

That Pats team that lost the first SB to the Giants was arguably the greatest team ever assembled....until Superbowl Sunday that is.

Some of y'all pay to much attention to Jaws, he has yall thinking Peyton is better than Brady.

he is better

 

[Gang$tarr]

Seeing how Peyton didn't do shyt but be a bum in both SBs he was in against worse defenses than the Giants, I'd say yes.

truth... peyton is a choke artist


dudes only superbowl is Vs. Rex Grossman nuff said

he is better

not in big moments aka superbowls

 

[JYoung24]

truth... peyton is a choke artist


dudes only superbowl is Vs. Rex Grossman nuff said





not in big moments aka superbowls

he played in against the top defense in the leauge that year in the rain a choke artist doesnt get to 2 superbowls and is one of the leaders in game winning drives

 

[Gang$tarr]

lol too bad those game winning drives dont come in important games. if u remember, he threw picks at the end of big games (playoffs) the last few years he played

when it comes to big games he chokes. he aint the same as he is in the reg season

 

[FTBS]

lol too bad those game winning drives dont come in important games. if u remember, he threw picks at the end of big games (playoffs) the last few years he played

when it comes to big games he chokes. he aint the same as he is in the reg season

Really what were these games? Because besides the SB none of them ring a bell.

Let's see,

Agaisnt the Jets there was no pick at the end.

Against the SD there was no pick at the end. I think there might have been when they played in 08 but I'm not sure off top. Either way your assertion lacks evidence.

BTW most qbs aren't the same in the playoffs as they are in the regular season. It's more difficult to play well in the playoffs.

 

[Real Talk of NY]

Seeing how those New England Squads that lost to the Giants in the Superbowl usually beat the Colts, I say yes.

 

[kevm3]

more like would peyton have lost against his little brother's TEAM, especially that defense? I would say yes.

 

[FTBS]

Seeing how those New England Squads that lost to the Giants in the Superbowl usually beat the Colts, I say yes.

The Pats lost to the Bills last year. they woulda beat the Giants? The Giants lost to the Seahawks and the Redskins twice last year. they woulda beat the Pats? That's flawed reasoning.

 

[Street Knowledge]

Really what were these games? Because besides the SB none of them ring a bell.

Let's see,

Agaisnt the Jets there was no pick at the end.

Against the SD there was no pick at the end. I think there might have been when they played in 08 but I'm not sure off top. Either way your assertion lacks evidence.

BTW most qbs aren't the same in the playoffs as they are in the regular season. It's more difficult to play well in the playoffs.

Manning has had some AWFUL playoff games and moments in big spots. But I don't remember any game losing picks at the end.( unless you count the pick against the saints which to be fair effectively ended the game)

 

[FTBS]

Manning has had some AWFUL playoff games and moments in big spots. But I don't remember any game losing picks at the end.( unless you count the pick against the saints which to be fair effectively ended the game)

No the pick against the Saints was a game-ender. That shyt was esque there is no denying that. I'm just tryna figure out how that shyt became plural.

 

[Real Talk of NY]

The Pats lost to the Bills last year. they woulda beat the Giants? The Giants lost to the Seahawks and the Redskins twice last year. they woulda beat the Pats? That's flawed reasoning.

Dude im talking about over the last decade how the Pats would mostly beat the Colts in the playoffs. The same Pats teams that lost 2x to the Giants in the Superbowl, and you talking about meaningless regular season games with the Bills, Seahawks, and Skins