I think people want to see more years of dominance before they compare Sherman to great wide receivers like Jerry Rice.
But COULD Sherman have shut down Rice for a game? Sure. Why not?
People have to understand that Jerry Rice didn't put up 120 yards receiving in every game of his career.
You can go into
www.pro-footballreference.com and see what Jerry Rice's game logs were.
He had games in his prime where he was held under 50 yards.
Now if you're asking me....if there was 1 game and I had to bet my life whether Rice would get shut down by Sherman? I'd bet on Rice gaining the upper hand.