Would you consider Eminem Top 5 in the long run?

[NerdBird]

After that mediocre album MMLP2 and his previous albums like Encore and Relapse, it's hard to legitimately have him as a top 5 rapper of all time.

 

[YeLovesBoston]

Am i the only one who loved MMLP2

 

[The Fire]

listen to cac rappers brehs

 

[mrken12]

Am i the only one who loved MMLP2

Yes.

 

[acri1]

Nope, he'd barely be in my top 20.

Lyrically he's very talented, but his content and replay value are . I mean he was cool back when I was in high school () when I used to listen to his tracks for shock value but most of his shyt has literally no long-term replay value. Vast majority of his songs are just him saying shyt for shock value and/or whining about how hard it is to be a rich celebrity.

 

[Mamimi]

his "classics" aged like shyt

even tyler the creator moved past edgy shock value rap

 

[Randoug]

On raw talent - Yes (I can't front, that pale demon can spit)
On musical output - No (One of the most inconsistent major rappers in terms of creating decent discography)

 

[...and some waffle fries]

Hi kids you wanna see violence....Fukk no

 

[NYtymes]

No

 

[SunZoo]

I'm his biggest fan on here and he's not cracking my top 5, not even because of his later albums but because the people who occupy those spots aren't going to be moved any time soon for various reasons.

 

[GoldTeef]

Top 20? Maybe. Top 5? Hell no

 

[EducatedBrothaFromTheBank]

He's just not a good rapper..

Outside of my top 30.. He's Chino XL if he was black

 

[cornercommission2k12]

Never considered him top anything

He benefited from black inferiority and Dr Dre wanting to tap into a white audience. Nothing more.

 

[cartierhoe]

Top 15 maybe

 

[DrunkerThanAMotherfucker]

He's one of the most ferocious spitters of all-time.

But he's got so many duds in his discography and on top of that he's corny 75% of the time.

Top 25-30 for me.