Marcus Spears proclaims Steve 'Air' McNair Best College QB EVER
Black Lightning
Superstar
It's between
or
or
Godless Socialist CEO
Superstar
It’s Cam or Vince. I never saw Steve play. Tebow was surrounded by nfl all pros. Not to mention maybe having the second greatest college football coach of all time running the program. I can’t name another player in those Auburn or Texas offenses
IsThatBrothaMouzone?
Superstar
Vince and Air McNair are among my favorites but Tommie does get overlooked.
Some of that is because Brooks Berringer (RIP) had quite a bit of success when TF was out with the blood clot in '94. But.....the way he tore up the Gators in the Fiesta Bowl was legendary. Those SEC squads learned a lot from watching that azz whooping. S&C matters.
Had Steve Spurrier looking like
IsThatBrothaMouzone?
Superstar
They were pretty stacked with Jamaal Charles being a freshman back up.
It makes you realize how much talent got wasted at Texas because they probably had more gifted teams before '05 that just couldn't win (Roy Williams, Derrick Johnson, Leonard Davis, Cedric Benson etc)
IsThatBrothaMouzone?
Superstar
USC in 04-05 was considered among the greatest teams ever. Bama was dominant but I don't think any of their squads were hyped like that...especially before Hurts/Tua.
LSU, Bama, and Georgia teams were stacked with All-Pro NFL talent breh.
Texas ran thru a trash Big 12 that season.
That Texas team was stacked with NFL talent.
While that Auburn team had one NFL bust.
Cam was more impressive.
you can tell these cats didn't see McNair, what made him special was the hype was unreal and once you saw him play he delivered on the hype.
AlbertPullhoez
The Takeover
FOH with that "Y'all never saw McNair play" shyt
I've seen plenty of McNair highlights and games at Alcorn. He was great but he not seeing Jameis in college
FOH with that "Y'all never saw McNair play" shyt
I've seen plenty of McNair highlights and games at Alcorn. He was great but he not seeing Jameis in college
Jameis
he's not even part of the discussionIt's Mac, Cam, Young and maybe Vick
I gotta put Watson in there too
AlbertPullhoez
The Takeover
Seriously???Jameis
It's Mac, Cam, Young and maybe Vick
Heisman winner as a RS freshman the youngest to win it, won a natty, 29-1 as a starter over 2 years, QB of the best offense in CFB history. Put up better numbers than McNair, Cam, and Vince while in a NFL pro style offense
First game as a starter he went 25/27 for 356 yards and 4 TD's on the road for fukk's sake
Jameis had 5 star talent on both sides of the ball. 2010 Auburn with Kelvin Benjamin(before he turned into an offensive tackleSeriously???
Heisman winner as a RS freshman the youngest to win it, won a natty, 29-1 as a starter over 2 years, QB of the best offense in CFB history. Put up better numbers than McNair, Cam, and Vince while in a NFL pro style offense
First game as a starter he went 25/27 for 356 yards and 4 TD's on the road for fukk's sake
) would've set every SEC offensive record.Cam single handedly willed that team through an undefeated SEC run to a national title.
Last edited:
Brandon M.
City of Angels
reggie bush
AlbertPullhoez
The Takeover
Jameis had 5 star talent on both sides of the ball. 2010 Auburn with Kelvin Benjamin(before he turned into an offensive tackle
Cam single handedly willed that team through an undefeated SEC run to a national title.
EJ Manuel played with that same talent and didnt come close to what Jameis did the very next year. I'll give Cam his props he was a beast too. But Jameis week after week in 2013 was doing shyt I aint never seen a QB do in college
My stepdad played against McNair in college. He played for JSU Gamecocks. They won the D2 championship I think in 92 and they played Alcorn State that year. He said McNair was the hardest mf to sack and was the best qb he had ever played against.