Long post incoming!
People who grew up along Murchison speak highly of it. You meet enough older people around the way who tell you it wasn't really until the 90s that Murchison started going downhill. Before then, aside from the projects areas of course, The Murk was mostly the standard for the black middle class in Fayetteville...
I'm 34 in two days, the people who can recount this are all generally my parents ages (who are mid and late 50s) or older, so basically people 50+ or born before '73 and native to Murchison/Ramsey, or lived in the area when it was as they described. I've met enough older people who've said this that I believe it, and I'm sure I've read an Observer article in the past like it, I'm gonna try to find it and link it here!
Now from my own experiences in the city, my introduction to Fayetteville was The Murk at 16 years old. My parents still live in the same house, up the street from that Cole video, that they moved into Fayetteville in, in '05. I've left Fayetteville several times over the last 18 years, and for years my parents have talked about leaving (my mom just mentioned it again earlier this week, she grew up between Western NY near Syracuse, and Memphis; said she wants to go back to Memphis). They've been talking about leaving Fayetteville almost the entire time they've been here
...
I never would have come back to Fayetteville or NC in general had my parents not stayed. We didn't have any ties here, no one is from here, I didn't grow up there or have string enough relationships with anyone that mattered. But my brother did one year of high school at Smith, went to FSU and fell in love with the city, he's 35 and has been in Fayetteville since he was 17, it's his city. And I think the reason my parents have stayed is mostly because of my dad (he's from Little Rock), he took an almost instant liking to the area. My mom, it had to grow on her. He's said numerous times he's open to leaving Fayetteville, but I think he's the reason they've never pulled the trigger...
For me, my parents became the only reason I'd come back. As an adult I've lived in VA twice, GA, NY, Charlotte, and Raleigh (now for the second time), and would come back to visit them, and it would suck me back in, I also moved back to Fayetteville a couple times. Always was ready to leave every time I got back, but it started growing on me too before I realized it---->my two oldest kids' mother grew up between Fayetteville and Raleigh, but I met her in Fayetteville...
My youngest daughter's mother, she grew up in and I met her in Fayetteville. And somewhere in my late 20s, the city started growing on me, I think in part, at some point I subconsciously noted that I'd watched this city grow for over a dozen years, I'd watched it change, every time I left and came back, there wad new changes for the better...
And for a brother like myself, I had an itinerant, transient, upbringing. I'm not "close, close" with my parents, but I'm closer to them now than I felt as a youth, abd I'm closer to them than my biological parents. I never had a home; though I recognize everywhere that I grew up along the way, I didn't have one home or sense of belonging to one specific place, I was a part of everywhere I'd been...
I didn't feel this with Fayetteville either, until 4 or 5 years ago, if that long. I didn't like NC that much nor Fayetteville, hated Raleigh the first time I moved there. It's grown on me too but not particularly enthralled by it now...but Fayetteville grew on me ..
I lived over off Cliffdale for a stretch, and down off Cumberland too. Met a variety of people and relationships, and to toe back into my central point, it's different on other sides of town. Each part of Fayetteville is different, each part of Black Fayetteville has its own twist, but Murchison and Ramsey, you can just tell it's different. It's the oldest part of Black Fayetteville, the university is there, and even longtime Fayettevillians who didn't grow up there, many can tell you that Murchison/Ramsey feels different...
It's the imprint of history in that area. Like you said Smith is damn near an HBCU, it's literally an extension of FSU. It's the only historically black high school, I mean Westover and 71st and Byrd became majority black high schools from the late 90s (Westover), 00s (First), and 10s (Byrd), as demographics shifted and more black people settled the hoods around those areas. But those aren't black areas generationally in Fayetteville. They became black areas. Murchison and Ramsey have ALWAYS been majority black neighborhoods and you can tell just learning the history of Fayetteville, and spending time in other parts of town...
I'm seriously, seriously considering a move back. My youngest daughter lives there, I'm only an hour out so I still see her often. But the move back is more about both cheaper cost of living and Fayetteville's continued growth, and how Fayetteville has resonated with me as sort of a hometown. And besides the immediate Westover area (Yadkin and Morganton), which has become an authentically black area but also has some diversity, the only areas I'll even consider moving to are The Murk or Ramsey----->because it's the black heartbeat of Fayetteville...
What years did you go to Smith and where do you live now? Would you ever live back in Fayetteville?