Wade vs Kobe: Who's better?

Who's the better shooting guard of all time?

  • Kobe

    Votes: 132 68.0%
  • Wade

    Votes: 62 32.0%

  • Total voters
    194

The Connoisseurs

Superstar
Joined
Jun 15, 2018
Messages
6,183
Reputation
1,044
Daps
22,262
Man stop it. 08-09 Wade I think I would put up against any Kobe season and take my chances but thats just 1 year. Forget the win shares, per, and other nerdy stats. Im just going off of what I saw Kobe was a more dominant player for a longer period of time and its not close.


Kobe never had a classic playoff run like 06 wade (he torched one the best defensive all time teams for 60% accuracy)Or even 05 wade , the one time Kobe could of had a classic series he threw it away to the Phoenix sun up 3-1 I believe ....

:yeshrug:
 

Primetime21

This my city
Supporter
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
45,165
Reputation
7,652
Daps
173,136
Reppin
Lemongrass, cherries, alkaline water
Kobe never had a classic playoff run like 06 wade (he torched one the best defensive all time teams for 60% accuracy)Or even 05 wade , the one time Kobe could of had a classic series he threw it away to the Phoenix sun up 3-1 I believe ....

:yeshrug:
You just named 2 seasons out of 20. Kobe's prime ran damn near twice as long as Wade's. Thats why he's above him he played at a higher level for a longer period of time.
 

onelastdeath

Banned
Joined
Jul 19, 2014
Messages
29,376
Reputation
11,012
Daps
134,991
Man stop it. 08-09 Wade I think I would put up against any Kobe season and take my chances but thats just 1 year. Forget the win shares, per, and other nerdy stats. Im just going off of what I saw Kobe was a more dominant player for a longer period of time and its not close.
The whole it’s not close thing is false. It’s close

Unless you’re talking about impact on basketball culture, it’s close .

The distance between wade and Kobe is a lot smaller than the distance between lebron and Kobe
 

The Connoisseurs

Superstar
Joined
Jun 15, 2018
Messages
6,183
Reputation
1,044
Daps
22,262
You just named 2 seasons out of 20. Kobe's prime ran damn near twice as long as Wade's. Thats why he's above him he played at a higher level for a longer period of time.

Kobe ain’t get poppin till the 2000 and his last couple years since like ‘11 we’re down years. He also had a couple down years when Shaq left..


Wade did enough after too I’m just naming classic stand alone moments like game winning blocks stuff(who is rare from a guard) or game winning steals ..
 

Primetime21

This my city
Supporter
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
45,165
Reputation
7,652
Daps
173,136
Reppin
Lemongrass, cherries, alkaline water
The whole it’s not close thing is false. It’s close

Unless you’re talking about impact on basketball culture, it’s close .

The distance between wade and Kobe is a lot smaller than the distance between lebron and Kobe
Yea alright. If Bron didnt punk out against the Mavs and Wade had gotten that 2nd finals MVP it could've been close.
 

Remote

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 29, 2013
Messages
85,998
Reputation
26,679
Daps
383,370
I’ll give it to Kobe for having the longevity.

But I think if you held it down to like, 5 year peak vs 5 year peak...it’s very close. And Wade may come out on top.

The titles argument does not interest me.
Kobe was certainly flashier. And that is something most of the casual fans can identify.
 

onelastdeath

Banned
Joined
Jul 19, 2014
Messages
29,376
Reputation
11,012
Daps
134,991
Yea alright. If Bron didnt punk out against the Mavs and Wade had gotten that 2nd finals MVP it could've been close.
Kobe doesn’t have a single better finals performance than 06 Wade (year 3 at that), nor does he have a better single season than 09 Wade

I say this as someone who ranks Kobe over him

But it ain’t THAT Far apart unless you’re talking about impact on basketball culture.
 

steph_harden

Superstar
Joined
Oct 25, 2017
Messages
6,610
Reputation
750
Daps
21,005
Man stop it. 08-09 Wade I think I would put up against any Kobe season and take my chances but thats just 1 year. Forget the win shares, per, and other nerdy stats. Im just going off of what I saw Kobe was a more dominant player for a longer period of time and its not close.

So we just going off eyetests now? Nevermind actual evidence. If we omit the stats then u could easily put AI over Wade the same way

Wade himself said Goatbe was better :mjlol:




Where do they find u nikkas :Docwtf:

Just asking a question fam...My opinion isn’t included in here at all. I just find it interesting how so many stats are overwhelmingly in Wade’s favor yet most people have Kobe leaps and bounds better.
 

Primetime21

This my city
Supporter
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
45,165
Reputation
7,652
Daps
173,136
Reppin
Lemongrass, cherries, alkaline water
Kobe doesn’t have a single better finals performance than 06 Wade (year 3 at that), nor does he have a better single season than 09 Wade

I say this as someone who ranks Kobe over him

But it ain’t THAT Far apart unless you’re talking about impact on basketball culture.
Again, I started off in this thread saying I'd take Wade's best season against Kobe's best individual season and feel good about my chances. But a career comparison cant be broken down to just 1 year. Kobe was a better player for a longer period of time, thats a snapple top fact.
 
Top