What sports team has the biggest disconnect with their perceived level of success to their actual?

Reality check

  • New York Knicks

    Votes: 103 49.5%
  • Atlanta Hawks

    Votes: 18 8.7%
  • The entire SEC outside of Alabama, auburn, georgia, FL and TN

    Votes: 21 10.1%
  • Philadelphia Eagles

    Votes: 21 10.1%
  • Chicago Whitesox

    Votes: 2 1.0%
  • Oregon Ducks

    Votes: 14 6.7%
  • Toronto Maple Leafs

    Votes: 10 4.8%
  • Canada in the Summer Olympics

    Votes: 2 1.0%
  • The Original Big east

    Votes: 2 1.0%
  • San Diego Chargers

    Votes: 3 1.4%
  • osu sucks

    Votes: 12 5.8%

  • Total voters
    208
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
76,529
Reputation
14,409
Daps
268,320
Reppin
206 & 734
37_6550A_lg.jpeg


Hawks won in '58



Lakers > Celtics. Lakers dominance is spread out. Celtics mostly dominated in the '60s. They have one championship in 28 years.
I'm confused where does that ring say ATLANTA hawks :ld:
 
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
76,529
Reputation
14,409
Daps
268,320
Reppin
206 & 734
The English National Soocer team hands down. Haven't won a World Cup since 1966, haven't been to a World Cup semi final since 1990, never won a Euro, and no Englishman has ever won a FIFA World Player of the Year award yet the English media acts like England is some sort of footballing powerhouse.
Thats a real good one actually
 

King Poetic

“ We are Men, Soldiers “
Supporter
Joined
Feb 15, 2013
Messages
110,062
Reputation
23,976
Daps
532,516
Reppin
Mid-City Los Angeles, California
1. the knicks -- i'm tired of hearing about the false claim of mecca of basketball

2. philadelphia eagles - i swear this team has won at least 2 superbowls by the way the east coast media and philly fans act

3. Gonzaga Basketball & Virginia Tech Football
 

L&HH

Veteran
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
53,932
Reputation
5,989
Daps
163,307
Reppin
PG x MD
Throw the Washington Redskins on that list and they'd get my vote.

Absolutely DIEHARD fans who think their team is among the elite, storied franchises in the league. Haven't won the ship since 91. Only 3 titles overall.
:dahell: you mean only. There's only 5 teams that have won more and only 6 teams with more appearances.

The Redskins are nowhere New York Knicks level of overratedness
 

L&HH

Veteran
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
53,932
Reputation
5,989
Daps
163,307
Reppin
PG x MD
My gawd this. Didn't have a clue how unbearable these nikkas were until I moved here. And that playoff appearance 2 seasons ago had me wanting to fight everyone. Seen nikkas rockin Heayh Shuler & Ricky Ervins jersey the week of the game. They legit swore they had a chance to win the super bowl

Well if RG3 was fully healthy who knows. We were up 14-0 on the Seahawks. The playoffs are all about getting hot at the right time, and as a matter of fact look at the Ravens who did win it. They were in the exact same predicament as us.

Also, this thread is not only about how that teams fan base in their respective hometowns perceived them. In that case every team would be overrated. It's also how the media portrays them. And as far as I know the media does not try and put on like the Redskins are some kind of powerhouse. But let's not act like the Cowboys aren't Super Bowl favorites every single year :beli:
 
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
76,529
Reputation
14,409
Daps
268,320
Reppin
206 & 734
Well if RG3 was full healthy who knows. We were up 14-0 on the Seahawks. The playoffs are all about getting hot at the right time as a matter of fact look at the Ravens who did win it. They were in the exact same predicament as us.

Also, this thread is not only about how that teams fan base in their respective hometowns perceived them. In that case every team would be overrated. It's also how the media portrays them. And as far as I know the media does not try and put on like the Redskins are some kind of powerhouse. But let's not act like the Cowboys aren't Super Bowl favorites every single year :beli:
The entire nfc east has an overinflated sense of self, but the hierarchy goes

  • Eagles (off the charts)
  • Cowboys (still somehow has 1990s expectations / self rating)
  • Skins (same as above, but comes down to earth quicker)
  • Giants (actually UNDERRATES their level of success, eli, and cruz would be GOD and ALLAH on the other 3 rosters)
 

L&HH

Veteran
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
53,932
Reputation
5,989
Daps
163,307
Reppin
PG x MD
The entire nfc east has an overinflated sense of self, but the hierarchy goes

  • Eagles (off the charts)
  • Cowboys (still somehow has 1990s expectations / self rating)
  • Skins (same as above, but comes down to earth quicker)
  • Giants (actually UNDERRATES their level of success, eli, and cruz would be GOD and ALLAH on the other 3 rosters)
:ehh: I'd agree with this ranking. I think you should have had the Cowboys in the poll though. For the simple fact that they're still running with this "America's Team" title. And because they're routinely picked every single year as upper Bowl favorites yet only have ONE playoff victory since they're SB in '96 to show for it.
 

Absolut

Superstar
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
15,896
Reputation
700
Daps
56,323
never hear anyone hyping up the white sox, chargers, or hawks really. on here atlanta fans here are delusional, but no one is saying shyt in public about the hawks being legit with a straight face. most people shyt on the lessers of the sec for that conference pride riding coattails bullshyt. no one cares about any canada teams. really only leaves the eagles, knicks and ducks. in terms of media hype, and fan base shyt talk its gotta be oregon. everyone swears they are a powerhouse, yet they aint winning shyt. got hyped to no end the last 2 seasons and couldnt even make a showing in their conference title game either year
 
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
76,529
Reputation
14,409
Daps
268,320
Reppin
206 & 734
never hear anyone hyping up the white sox, chargers, or hawks really. on here atlanta fans here are delusional, but no one is saying shyt in public about the hawks being legit with a straight face. most people shyt on the lessers of the sec for that conference pride riding coattails bullshyt. no one cares about any canada teams. really only leaves the eagles, knicks and ducks. in terms of media hype, and fan base shyt talk its gotta be oregon. everyone swears they are a powerhouse, yet they aint winning shyt. got hyped to no end the last 2 seasons and couldnt even make a showing in their conference title game either year
Who is favorite in the Michigan State @ oregon game this year in most books? I have a feeling msu is gonna fukk em up...
 

BigE214

Future GOAT
Joined
Aug 20, 2012
Messages
12,009
Reputation
2,075
Daps
25,976
Reppin
Groveside, TX
The entire nfc east has an overinflated sense of self, but the hierarchy goes

  • Eagles (off the charts)
  • Cowboys (still somehow has 1990s expectations / self rating)
  • Skins (same as above, but comes down to earth quicker)
  • Giants (actually UNDERRATES their level of success, eli, and cruz would be GOD and ALLAH on the other 3 rosters)
You'd be pressed to fine anyone else that agrees with this.

edit: :dead: @ the thought of a Boys fan wanting Cruz over Dez
 
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
76,529
Reputation
14,409
Daps
268,320
Reppin
206 & 734
You'd be pressed to fine anyone else that agrees with this.

edit: :dead: @ the thought of a Boys fan wanting Cruz over Dez
I didnt suggest that at all, but i'm discussing how they'd be respected by their fanbase

Eli
2 superbowls
2 superbowl mvps
You tell me how this man would be treated in dallas.

Cruz
3626 yards, 23 tds vs

Dez since 2011
3543 yards, 34 tds (way more redzone targets)

Tell me how cruz would be treated in dallas
 
Last edited:
Top