When healthy who is the better WR: Dez Bryant or Hakeem Nicks

Who is better


  • Total voters
    88

Thegospel

Superstar
Joined
Sep 28, 2012
Messages
22,871
Reputation
-6,729
Daps
47,037
Reppin
NULL
This is where dez ranks all time in first three yrs of his career

1 Randy Moss (1998-2000) 226 rec 4163 yds 43 td
2 Jerry Rice (1985-1987) 200 rec 3575 yds 40 td
3 John Jefferson (1978-1980) 199 rec 3431 yds 36 td
4 Bob Hayes (1965-1967) 160 rec 3253 yds 35 td
5 Dez Bryant (2010-2012) 200 rec 2871 yds 27 td


like i said. these nikkas is EMOTIONAL.lol hating and lying their ass off. bu bu bu Nicks proved more!
 

Thegospel

Superstar
Joined
Sep 28, 2012
Messages
22,871
Reputation
-6,729
Daps
47,037
Reppin
NULL
Meek Mill was right. The internet is funny because you can get on here and say whatever you want to just for the fukk of it. lol at this poll being so close. and lol at nikkas not watching the game when they showed replays of Dez getting double/triple teamed. Disgusting. Reminding me why I hate everything related to New York.
 

who_better_than_me

Time to go!!
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
27,925
Reputation
1,380
Daps
42,145
Reppin
NULL
LMAO at Dez getting "triple teamed"... when the giants played zone all night.
At one point romo threw forces pass towards Dez with 3 giants defender less than 5 feet away. U watched that game nigguh. The announcers kept saying the whole game they"re giving dez all the attention
 

CaughtInTWebb

All Star
Supporter
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
7,015
Reputation
954
Daps
12,330
Reppin
Big D, Texas
This is where dez ranks all time in first three yrs of his career

1 Randy Moss (1998-2000) 226 rec 4163 yds 43 td
2 Jerry Rice (1985-1987) 200 rec 3575 yds 40 td
3 John Jefferson (1978-1980) 199 rec 3431 yds 36 td
4 Bob Hayes (1965-1967) 160 rec 3253 yds 35 td
5 Dez Bryant (2010-2012) 200 rec 2871 yds 27 td


My God at Moss numbers......now I seriously see why Rice was legit mad at dude....he could've shattered his records....
 

Heelmatic

The Carolina Blueprint
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
9,298
Reputation
1,187
Daps
17,398
Reppin
NC
People are clearly letting their emotions cloud the facts. I still havent seen anyone claiming Nicks has proven more than Dez tell me how many touchdowns Nicks has in his first 3 years. For the record they came in the same year. The fact that Dez was still learning and finally caught on last year and STILL puts up numbers is proof that anyone saying Nicks is better is hating/lying. Like, I'm really offended by this question.lol You compare Dez to Julio, AJ, Fitz. Not Hakeem Nicks. He is second tier.
For the record, no they didn't.

Can we look at the stats for the 1st 3 years then if that's what you want? This doesn't include playoffs..

Hakeem Nicks - 3,074 yds...24 tds....42 games played

Dez Bryant - 2,871 yds...27 tds...43 games played
 

Scorsese

Pro
Joined
Mar 18, 2013
Messages
624
Reputation
440
Daps
2,408
Reppin
NULL
Nicks

Dez is the more Physically Gifted/Blessed... But Hakeem is the more technically impressive.

Plus, as has already been mentioned in here, Nicks's 2011 Post Season Performance >>>>> Anything Dez has yet done
 

Codeine Bryant

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Nov 19, 2012
Messages
11,811
Reputation
3,340
Daps
46,405
Reppin
DFW
Emmitt Smith is better than Barry Sanders because of what Emmitt did in the playoffs. Come talk to me when Barry puts up 100+ rushing yards and multiple TDs in games where trophies are on the line :troll:

By using the playoff argument, all the Hakeem Nicks supporters are basically saying Nicks >>>>> Julio, AJ Green, Andre Johnson, Calvin Johnson, Dez Bryant, Brandon Marshall
 

Prodyson

All Star
Joined
May 22, 2012
Messages
4,028
Reputation
1,043
Daps
11,771
People saying either one of these receivers is clearly better than the other is either a hater, a homer, or a follower. Dez is a freak athletically, but he's not as skilled a receiver as Nicks.... plus Nicks just has a god given advantage with those huge hands. People using the fact the Dez couldn't even remember his routes as a reason why he's better (since he still put up good numbers) are delusional. Being able to remember and run routes is a part of being a receiver. Plus... As suspect as Tony Romo is, he is a slinger. He's putting the ball in the air. Eli Manning, not so much. Especially earlier in Nicks' career. The Giants running game was utilized much more than Cowboys. The Giants had Brandon Jacobs to punch in Touchdowns... who did the Cowboys have?

The only reason Nicks isn't widely revered the way Dez is, is because the nikka is always injured. But that is also factored in when determining how good a WR is. If you can't stay on the field, you can't prove yourself :manny:
 

who_better_than_me

Time to go!!
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
27,925
Reputation
1,380
Daps
42,145
Reppin
NULL
For the record, no they didn't.

Can we look at the stats for the 1st 3 years then if that's what you want? This doesn't include playoffs..

Hakeem Nicks - 3,074 yds...24 tds....42 games played

Dez Bryant - 2,871 yds...27 tds...43 games played
Nicks started 38 of those 42 games. Dez started only 29.
 

yseJ

Empire strikes back
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
47,940
Reputation
2,969
Daps
70,968
Reppin
The Yay
My God at Moss numbers......now I seriously see why Rice was legit mad at dude....he could've shattered his records....
those are first three years

lets look at last three years of their careers and how old they were at that point :troll:
 
Top