You're an NFL GM on the Clock. Would you risk it all on Tua?

[producingfire]

You are an NFL General manager and your job depends on this draft. Are you mortgaging the future on Tua? Or is Tua too much of an injury risk to bet the future on? You would either have to trade up in the first round to get him, or draft him within the top 5 picks. The risk here is that another team could trade up, that was initially behind you.

If you take the Gamble and Tua flops, you're out
If you don't take the gamble and Tua is Patrick Mahomes esque, you're out.

 

[Ohene]

where am i picking from and who is on the board

Tua overrated imo

 

[Thavoiceofthevoiceless]

He’s worth the gamble if you give him a redshirt year. You’d need a bridge starter and a competent backup so there’s no rush or urgency to bring him into the field.

It’s the exact reason why Miami and only Miami is the ideal scenario for him. Other teams ahead of them know that which is why they are putting out false rumors to get them to move up.

 

[King Poetic]

No if your Washington cause Chase Young will be a beast and you need someone to get to the quarterbacks

yes if your Miami , cause you need everything

 

[producingfire]

where am i picking from and who is on the board

Tua overrated imo

Well in that situation I guess it would be a "no" but imagine you had the ability to get him in the first round. but you either had to trade up to get him, or you have a top 5 pick.

 

[producingfire]

He’s worth the gamble if you give him a redshirt year. You’d need a bridge starter and a competent backup so there’s no rush or urgency to bring him into the field.

It’s the exact reason why Miami and only Miami is the ideal scenario for him. Other teams ahead of them know that which is why they are putting out false rumors to get them to move up.

Imagine Tua in Dallas someway somehow lol

 

[producingfire]

No if your Washington cause Chase Young will be a beast and you need someone to get to the quarterbacks

yes if your Miami , cause you need everything

I'm not sure, Are you sold on Haskins though bro?

 

[Thavoiceofthevoiceless]

Well in that situation I guess it would be a "no" but imagine you had the ability to get him in the first round. but you either had to trade up to get him, or you have a top 5 pick.

Theoretically, Miami necessarily doesn’t have to move up from 5 to get him as I don’t see any other team jumping them to get him based on the injury.

Some people forget that he’s had two ankle surgeries on top of the hip injury in the past 2 seasons.

 

[Thavoiceofthevoiceless]

I'm not sure, Are you sold on Haskins though bro?

Even if you weren’t, putting him in Washington would put immense pressure on them to play him sometime this year the moment that the team and/or Haskins struggles.

 

[producingfire]

Theoretically, Miami necessarily doesn’t have to move up from 5 to get him as I don’t see any other team jumping them to get him based on the injury.

Meanwhile they are saying they may give up 2-3 round picks just to go up 3 spots, but if I'm going to do that I may go and just get Joe Burrow. by forfeiting all of my first round picks to Cinci

 

[TUA TAGOVAILOA]

where am i picking from and who is on the board

Tua overrated imo

What makes you say he is overrated?

 

[producingfire]

Even if you weren’t, putting him in Washington would put immense pressure on them to play him sometime this year the moment that the team and/or Haskins struggles.

They went and gave up a 5th rounder for Kyle Allen. Even if Haskins struggles they can go that route for a while. They also suprisingly haven't given up on Alex Smith, who they expect for him to make a recovery and come back.

 

[PortCityProphet]

Unbiasedly....yep taking him. He's a supreme QB talent and the best one in the draft. Dude can make all the throws, was athletic in the pocket, his biggest fault is he's greedy and he'll predetermine throws ahead of the snap.
I think the injury might make him chill on his greed cause thats the reason he got injured in the 1st place. And predetermined reads is something that can be coached too.
But I've watched him for 3 years, he's the real deal, not many weaknesses in his game.

 

[producingfire]

Unbiasedly....yep taking him. He's a supreme QB talent and the best one in the draft. Dude can make all the throws, was athletic in the pocket, his biggest fault is he's greedy and he'll predetermine throws ahead of the snap.
I think the injury might make him chill on his greed cause thats the reason he got injured in the 1st place. And predetermined reads is something that can be coached too.
But I've watched him for 3 years, he's the real deal, not many weaknesses in his game.

Farve was greedy and risky, but Green Bay still got one Superbowl from him. I think Tua has a great chance of success if he can sit a year. The problem is the team that takes him has to resist the urge to play him now.

 

[Ohene]

What makes you say he is overrated?

iunno man, since that first year where he took over for Hurts, he just never really did anything that stood out to me
Joe Burrow in another world to me