05' Steve Nash or 11'Derrick Rose?

[ManBearPig]

Both players got a lot have hate after winning their MVPs even after nobody gave them a chance before the season started. Both led their teams to the best record in the NBA and went to the Conference Finals and lose in 5. Their season were very identical. Who was more impressive.

 

[MJ Freedom]

Just based off liking to watch Nash more, I voted him. The Black in me (pause) damn near made me vote D. Rose off GP though.

 

[Mandizi]

I pick Rose based off who would win in a 1-on-1 matchup. Would have Nash at 31 lookin like he's 41.

 

[ManBearPig]

I pick Rose based off who would win in a 1-on-1 matchup. Would have Nash at 31 lookin like he's 41.

Rose better not turn that ball over

 

[Tony D'Amato]

Nash. Derrick Rose has always been overrated to me. Especially as a point guard

 

[Draje]

Nash led teams to top tier offenses. The Bulls were a defensive team that had Rose as it's Main offensive option.

Gimme Nash. I don't care about PG defense enough unless you're an absolute game changer like Payton or Kidd.

 

[JahFocus CS]

Tough choice. I say Nash because he was a better playmaker IMO.

 

[The Goodz]

29 to 62 wins because of Nash >>>>>anything D Rose has done

 

[Tunez]

Kidd in 03

 

[mrken12]

Rose because he actually tried to play defense.

 

[NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong]

Ill take the player that plays defense and was more dynamic offensively without an offensive system in place to boost stats and offensive talent around him to boost them further

 

[NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong]

barbosa, diaw, bell, house, jackson, jones, stoudemire, marion, kurt thomas and tim thomas with d'antoni as coach. #1 in league in pts and pace and 28th/30th in team defense. that was 05-06

in 04-05 they had barbosa, jackson, joe johnson, marion, q rich and stoudemire. 1st in points and pace, last in defense. nash was 4th on his own team in PPG, barely above qrich. the poll being this close is sad

 

[GunRanger]

The man who led great teams for almost a decade. Easily.

He could also spread the floor

 

[dh86]

Bulls won because of defense and rebounding which Rose had a nominal part in. Suns won because of efficient offense wholly based around Steve Nash

 

[Jplaya2023]

the suns with mvp level d gawd will a few rings

05 06 and 07 their in the finals at the very least