no son, I'm a fan of hip hop since 1984. Roots of Evil at best is G raps 4th best album. MOT is not every Gang Starr fan's best album, but a majority of them I've heard over the years(not all) have stated this is the one where they figured it out and unintentionally crossed over. And yes I was a Gang Starr fan since 89. Attended one of their concerts, Spoke to the whole crew. Now I'm not saying Either Guru or Pun are better than G rap. G rap is one of my personal favorites of all time. Him and Rakim. Chuck D is also one of my all time favorites (PE is my favorite group). An album consists of beats AND lyrics. Beats on Roots of evil were dope(especially the Stephani Mills sample used by Pudgee and Lost Boyz 2 years prior) but there is no way on earth that was a better album than MOT. no way, no how. Biggie came from Kane's family tree, are we to also believe Daddy's Home was better than Ready to Die? And I liked Daddy's Home too.
For the record, my house is like a goddamn museum of hip hop books, mags(literally decades worth), vinyl, cds, cassettes, show fliers, posters, equipment(3 sets of turntables, and cassettes I personally recoded hip hop programs off the radio over 30 years ago until around 2004. So no, I'm not a casual.... I lived it in real time just like you so I won't get caught up in this, "I'm more hip hop than you cuz I like this albums better"