$3000 a week but live in NYC or $900 a week but live in small southern town

Who has more money after bills and living expenses

  • NYC person

    Votes: 23 82.1%
  • Small town person

    Votes: 5 17.9%

  • Total voters
    28

BrothaZay

Non-FBA. AdosK
Supporter
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
64,831
Reputation
6,395
Daps
223,256
Reppin
The suburbs
Which person do you think ends up saving more money? Or better yet, who ends up with more discretionary income ?

Both have an apartment they rent

No roommates

Both have to get to work(not close enough to walk for either)

No kids


No school debt for either


For sake of argument the small town is in Tennessee(no state tax )
 

Ezekiel 25:17

Veteran
Joined
Jul 17, 2018
Messages
36,609
Reputation
2,886
Daps
130,390
Is that gross or net income?

If we go by gross income, that's $7600/month. 5% 401k & health insurance, figure your take home is $7000/month. Rent, utilities, and food will be your highest expenses. I'd budget $5000/month just for those 3. Public transportation should be what, another $500? That leaves you with $1500/month.

I think the NY person will have more income leftover vs. the small town person.
 
Last edited:

Bolzmark

Superstar
Joined
May 23, 2012
Messages
8,617
Reputation
1,362
Daps
28,420
Reppin
ATL
Even in NY $3000/week is very good money. You can get a decent one bedroom apartment in Brooklyn for $3K. That leaves you with $9000 for the month to spend. Make it $1500/week for a more interesting hypothetical.
 

Mystic

Superstar
Joined
Nov 10, 2015
Messages
11,622
Reputation
-513
Daps
18,832
Which person do you think ends up saving more money? Or better yet, who ends up with more discretionary income ?

Both have an apartment they rent

No roommates

Both have to get to work(not close enough to walk for either)

No kids


No school debt for either


For sake of argument the small town is in Tennessee(no state tax )
I already live in a small southern town so give me the small southern town
 

Savvir

Veteran
Joined
Oct 8, 2014
Messages
21,333
Reputation
3,599
Daps
110,260
Is that gross or net income?

If we go by gross income, that's $7600/month. 5% 401k & health insurance, figure your take home is $7000/month. Rent, utilities, and food will be your highest expenses. I'd budget $5000/month just for those 3. Public transportation should be what, another $500? That leaves you with $1500/month.

I think the NY person will have more income leftover vs. the small town person.
Your number are off..

Just ran a tax calculator… take home would be roughly $8,400
 
Top